well, you should also understand that Vika's goal is not to justify the maphacker, but to teach how to corner maphackers so that it is obvious to the entire community :)
It's even surprising that people are so weak in their arguments, clinging to all sorts of nonsense, and allowing themselves to be flooded with irrelevant information. I would build the line of accusation completely differently - I would choose several specific episodes (the criteria are described above), and present the rest as a background that is not supposed to be analyzed in detail.