What can be done with the "traffic light" can also be done with Artmana. Whether the player broke the game or not is up to the moderator to decide.

The question is, what criteria should be used to decide? The patch provides a DEFINITIVE answer. But without it... Let's read posts from supposedly experienced players.

And besides, if I have +1 to morale, then I consider it legitimate to generate morale in the first round of a critical battle.

and the moderator, in turn, has to process a certain number of such requests. I suggest limiting the number of battle retries to 50.

Interesting, have you considered that, probabilistically (without the "traffic light"), the moderator might not even get a morale boost in one turn after 50 retries? The probability of such an event is not small, approximately 11.7%. And if there are several such battles and requests in a walkthrough? After all, it has to happen in all battles. So, according to your algorithm, with 5-6 morale boosts in a walkthrough, the moderator should declare a person a cheater with a probability of around 0.5. This is, of course, a rough example, but it demonstrates that either the number of attempts needs to be increased to the heavens (poor moderators), or the algorithm doesn't work.

I think that a significant number of different tactical options will be developed with this same patch; here, it's a matter of technique and desire... In the end, it's too early to predict how things will turn out. It would be nice if it just turns out to be a loud firework for the enjoyment of children and moderators... But what if we've opened Pandora's Box?

What Pandora's Box? People have been playing like this in the second game for many years. In the fifth game, a huge number of potential battle parameters are embedded when generating the save, and it doesn't matter how you got to the battle. And as a person who periodically plays all three mentioned games, I'll say that with 100% reproducibility, the STRATEGY of the battle comes to the forefront, rather than the idol of "freebies" and a shamanic drum.