Heroes 5 – “A masterpiece or an unfinished product?”

I think this topic should be closed, dear moderators, because in the debate of whether it's a masterpiece or a failure, we each have our own opinion... (for me, it's a masterpiece). And in the end, there are other topics where those who have played the game can express their opinion, or those who haven't played (but they should play it first, and then talk).
For example, the topic "Heroes of Might and Magic V! Game Discussion!" could include everything we've been discussing here.

P.S. But that's just my opinion.