The rules state that you should agree individually with each player.
With your scheme, only Ramparts, Dungeons, and Castles will be played. The proposed scheme has proven itself on many resources.
This is to prevent the following situation: when a player attacks another, hits with magic, and then pays them off. Then they attack again, hit with magic, and pay them off. I think the explanation is clear.
Everything is tracked very easily by the save files.
P.S. I'm not being difficult, but I think these questions are important. Sincerely, Kamikaze!
