Mafia 112. Pirates of the HW Sea

But during both instances when Jones summoned the ship in the movie, he also sank it. Whether it was the one Will was hiding on or the Black Pearl. Here, we can assume that both ultimates trigger the battle description.

And overall, as I said at the beginning: it's impossible to distinguish the abilities from each other in this situation.

You can be an optimist (the ultimate was used), or a pessimist (the ultimate wasn't used), but it's unlikely that you'll be able to convince each other.