Discussions, post-mortems, analysis, inflated egos, and all that jazz.

His position is really simple – a fan of Shades of Darkness, a hater of Heroes of Might and Magic. But it's never clear why.

Alfein, you're trying again to find complexity in simplicity. In my phrase, the words "simple" and "clear" simply reinforce each other and essentially explain the same thing. Simple means "not complex," and clear means "not complex" in terms of perception.
What specifically in SirDavos's posts and position is unclear to you?