Skip to content

New rules for submitting maps.

User Avatar
#48
Auto-translated
I agree, it took a while.

So.
1) Change the title: add the map type. This option is more popular than adding sections, and we will implement it.

It's getting complicated. Only 18 people voted (2 in the thread voted for "leave it as is"). So, besides this option, no other option reaches half of the votes. Therefore, I reason as follows: I look at similar options in meaning/purpose. I calculate the total number of votes (I don't count the same people twice). If it's more than or equal to half, we implement the most popular option. Do you agree?

2) This item has no similar options, and there are few people in favor of it. -
3) This item has the same function as items 4, 8, and 9 – to deal with old maps (which are mostly "foreign" maps). We count them together; for these items, we have the votes of Antik, AstralLein, psatkha, Lux in tenebris, Andrail, Rolf, Dyrman, Anton Turov, atlant108. That's 9 people. Is that enough? Well, barely. You can also count me as a supporter of this change; that will be enough. But item 3 is not the most popular in this group.
4) And this one is the most popular. It goes into production.
5) Similar to 6). We need to remove unnecessary information and shorten the title; otherwise, there will be a problem with modifying the titles. There are eight people for these two items. Counting me, that's nine. This is not good and is a small number, but the point is important. Item 4 definitely doesn't make sense without this. In general, it goes into production.
6) Same as 5.
7) Same as 1.
8) Same as 4.
9) Same as 4.

That is, items 1, 4, and 5.

For the sake of fairness, we can create another poll, such as "Which is better, items 1, 4, and 5 or just item 1," to eliminate doubts about the correctness of the choice. But, it seems to me that it will point in that direction.

If there are no objections, I will start renaming the topics this weekend.

Thank you all for your participation and comments.

Regarding how to rename:
Ideally, the topic title should be:
Map type (single/campaign/multiplayer) - Map name in the original language - Map size in the form of a single letter - Map author

For example:
Scenario: Journey[L] - Dyrman
Or even more likely, according to a slightly later template:
Scenario[L]: "Journey" - Dyrman
 

К А
Стикеры GBF в Telegram