Mafia 105. Raid of the Damned — Mafia

ToX

9 years ago

Auto-translated

I also want to share my final thoughts on the game. Congratulations to Ment for the formal victory. >:3 I suppose he is the best player in this round. The Mafia players also did well; I was even rooting for them, but towards the end of the game, I remembered that they killed Morny and Nefela first – and you can't kill cute characters right away. Maybe they just read my previous Mafia games, saw that they won as the Mafia, and decided to eliminate him just in case. XD Actually, thank you all for the game. It was very interesting for me. You are all great. One question for Revan. Bro, why did you release Ment from the frog? You seemed to suspect that he was the Mafia at that point. If you had continued to control him, I think the town would have won, and you would have been the MVP. XD I liked this setting; maybe in the future, I will continue the story of Kenkael. I tried to create an atmosphere and immerse you in it. I hope I succeeded. Of course, if you look at it from the perspective of a SERIOUS GAME, then it probably failed in that regard. Almost everyone quickly forgot about the 18-hour night rule, including myself. XD There was instability over time, and I also chatted a lot, which is not ideal for a GM. However, I believe that it turned out well, that the game was a success, and that I will personally consider this Mafia game a successful one. I am glad that I had the honor of being your GM during the New Year holidays. I hope you were satisfied. I would like to host another Mafia game sometime, so I am looking forward to feedback from the players. Regarding the clues, the atmosphere, the lore, and the mechanics. I tried my best, but if you didn't like something, please tell me directly, and I will take your opinion into account. In short, once again: thank you all, I am sincerely grateful to you for playing in my game. I was happy to try my best for you. よろしくね～！

kcfgogbfalgfl

9 years ago

Auto-translated

One question for Revan. Dude, why did you release Ment from the frog? You seemed to suspect at that time that he was a...

As the first few days showed, the city needs corpses; otherwise, it won't start moving and executing those who deserve it.

In reply to kcfgogbfalgfl

KindShaman

9 years ago

Auto-translated

Azuchi

As the first few days have shown, the city needs corpses; otherwise, it won't start to stir and execute those who deserve it.

But if there are corpses, there's simply no one left to execute...

kcfgogbfalgfl

9 years ago

Auto-translated

Well, yes, the city lost from day one.

Ment

9 years ago

Auto-translated

As the first few days have shown, the city needs corpses; otherwise, it won't start moving and executing those who deserve it.

Luckily, "those who deserve it" turned out not to be me. x)

In reply to Fragment

MasteR

9 years ago

Auto-translated

Fragment

What can I say, the result was predictable. The town didn't do much on its own to achieve victory, except perhaps for the role of the Sky, and even that wasn't without my help. The Maniac turned out to be quite overpowered, with three defenses, one of which couldn't even be penetrated by a damage dealer, and he also had the highest priority. Well, and an auto-win, of course.

Master, how can you play like that, seriously? Every time I mafia a peaceful player in front of you, people in the chat make fun of your reasoning. You could at least read the rules more often or clarify unclear points with the Game Master... Mold also played well; a guaranteed peaceful role is essentially the town's main hope in a daytime game, but he didn't seem to care. The Cop played well, he had a good game, but overall, he didn't face any particular difficulties, except perhaps keeping an eye on the role-players during the day. Neyra and Sky weren't very active, but they still contributed to the team's game. It was great playing with Yashchur; he really has a good intuition. He was mainly responsible for figuring out the roles of the peaceful players and compiling the night's actions, along with Sky, and they did quite well. And his emotions are just amazing, haha.

The game turned out to be a bit rushed for me; I didn't expect to be so busy in the pre-New Year week. I thought I had fallen behind and wouldn't be able to get back into the game, but no, I quickly figured things out, and my activity picked up. Although, during the day, I had to play not as I wanted, but as the situation required, which was quite difficult.

But overall, I enjoyed the game. We could have won if we had been a little luckier. Thank you to Tox, he's a really interesting Game Master, thank you to my team and everyone else for the game. Congratulations to the Cop on the victory!

If you're all such tacticians and role-players, why didn't you kill the Maniac when you had the chance? Instead, you revealed yourselves when defending the Sky.
I said that playing a game during the New Year holidays was a bad idea. I had to monitor the game on my phone almost all the time, which was very inconvenient for me.

Added after 32 seconds
The Cop "played well," he only targeted the town

Ment

9 years ago

Auto-translated

The cop was a "good guy," only attacking the city.

Otherwise, it would have been riskier during the day.

If you're all such tacticians and strategists, why didn't you kill the maniac when you had the chance? Instead, you blew your cover while defending Haven and got slaughtered.

And I'm hard to kill for them. There was a moment when Marianne could have quickly taken me out, but otherwise, they would have had to spend at least two nights trying to kill me.

MasteR

9 years ago

Auto-translated

Yeah, it’s better to wait until the city hands the Mafia a victory on a silver platter.

ToX

9 years ago

Auto-translated

Marianna couldn't attack, just so you know :D

Ment

9 years ago

Auto-translated

Ah, well, that makes even more sense. I just got myself comfortable.

In reply to MasteR

Злобный Ящур

9 years ago

Auto-translated

MasteR

If you're all such tacticians and calculators, why didn't you kill the maniac when you had the chance?

"Lizard Council" (GM and somas understand what I mean :D) decided that the town was so messed up that they would go defend it or heal it. And they weren't wrong...:mad:

MasteR

Instead, they got wiped out while defending Heaven.

They decided that without Heaven, they couldn't do anything against you and Ment, so either save Heaven (if Gur had stolen the voice from whoever he needed to), or die.

MasteR

Ment was "great," he only attacked the town.

That's where you belong...:mad:

Added 4 minutes later

MasteR

Yeah, it's better to wait for the town to hand the victory to the mafia on a silver platter.

If I try to explain why it would have been beneficial for the town to execute Ment (back then, when I suggested it, and not when he put the town on par with the mafia), would it be worth it? Or shouldn't I even try?:(

In reply to Злобный Ящур

MasteR

9 years ago

Auto-translated

Evil Lizard

"If I try to explain why the town benefited from the execution of Ment (when I suggested it, not when he made the town equal to the Mafia), would it be helpful? Or shouldn't I even try?:("

When? When we executed the Mafia boss, Lizard, or when we executed Mafia-Heaven, with the overpowered kill? Both executions by the town were correct in terms of goals. In the first 2 days, there was no point in executing anyone, as there were no significant reasons to do so.
It's interesting how you think we should have left the Mafia alone and executed the Serial Killer. No, we needed to solve all the issues ourselves at night, not wait for gifts from the town. Why did you go and kill the Shaman? You left the town with a choice – give the victory to the Serial Killer or the Mafia. And that's the result you got.

In reply to MasteR

Злобный Ящур

9 years ago

Auto-translated

MasteR

When? When did we execute the Mafia boss Yashur, or when did we execute Mafia-Heaven, with that overpowered kill?

When the Mafia boss Yashur was executed.

MasteR

Interesting, so we should have left the Mafia alone and executed the serial killer.

Okay. You hanged the Mafia member, and then what? You lost two townies, one of whom had an impenetrable block, and the other steals votes. Are you happy?

MasteR

No, we should have solved all the problems ourselves at night, instead of waiting for gifts from the town. Why did you go and kill the Shaman?

So that the victory wouldn't go to the town, which didn't deserve it...:p

P.S. I see now. The Serial Killer = Stronghold, you can't hang him (or rather, you can't hang him right away, but it's too late later), the town's goal is not to win itself, but to bring the Serial Killer to victory...