Auto-translated
Since there's no response to my post on the IRMG forum about version 1.7.9, and the discussion is happening here, I'll share my thoughts:
I suspect that version 1.7.9 of the generator isn't generating starting zones correctly (a mountain in the middle of the starting zone or a sausage-shaped starting zone). Moreover, the old templates were used (which haven't been updated for about a year).
Daniel and I played at least 20 games (probably more) on version 1.7.9, using the old templates, and it almost always generated starting zones like the ones I described – at least one of the two players experienced this, and the other might have been luckier.
We reverted to the previous generator, kept the same templates, and played a few games – the difference was huge, and the problems described above were practically gone (at least, there wasn't a mountain in the starting zone even once).
I won't argue with DVP or Moz – they know better what might be causing the problems I described (IRMG or the template itself). So, this is just a theory.
But the situation is as I described it. This is how it works in practice.
I admit that this might just be Daniel's and my impression. Maybe everyone else is generating everything perfectly in version 1.7.9 and has no problems. In that case, we can close the issue.
P.S. In my administrative work, there have been several cases where I said, "This can't be happening because it's impossible." And then it turned out that it could happen if certain stars aligned in a specific way. The same might be true here – let's sit down and carefully analyze the situation. I'm not against new versions (of the generator or the templates). I just want to have versions in the tournament that don't have any issues. And we won't need to revert to the previous version in the middle of the tournament.
I suspect that version 1.7.9 of the generator isn't generating starting zones correctly (a mountain in the middle of the starting zone or a sausage-shaped starting zone). Moreover, the old templates were used (which haven't been updated for about a year).
Daniel and I played at least 20 games (probably more) on version 1.7.9, using the old templates, and it almost always generated starting zones like the ones I described – at least one of the two players experienced this, and the other might have been luckier.
We reverted to the previous generator, kept the same templates, and played a few games – the difference was huge, and the problems described above were practically gone (at least, there wasn't a mountain in the starting zone even once).
I won't argue with DVP or Moz – they know better what might be causing the problems I described (IRMG or the template itself). So, this is just a theory.
But the situation is as I described it. This is how it works in practice.
I admit that this might just be Daniel's and my impression. Maybe everyone else is generating everything perfectly in version 1.7.9 and has no problems. In that case, we can close the issue.
P.S. In my administrative work, there have been several cases where I said, "This can't be happening because it's impossible." And then it turned out that it could happen if certain stars aligned in a specific way. The same might be true here – let's sit down and carefully analyze the situation. I'm not against new versions (of the generator or the templates). I just want to have versions in the tournament that don't have any issues. And we won't need to revert to the previous version in the middle of the tournament.
Будьте осторожны со своими желаниями. Иногда они исполняются.