Posts from Mafia 101. Disputed Island

And if I were executed and my role was revealed, would you blame Yashur?

Yashur has a role that the mafia wouldn't be able to handle without compromising themselves, and they need to do it before 5 AM. It was beneficial for them to cast suspicion on him and push for his elimination.

Freedom, Independence, 98 - Armageddon - Michael Bay - Pearl Harbor - Hawaii - Maui (KindShaman)

The solution is beautiful, but not correct. And yes, good evening everyone. I still like the solution for Alex.
Execute Alexeagle

The solution is beautiful, but not correct. And yes, good evening everyone. I still like the solution for Alex.
Execute Alexeagle

How about suggesting the correct one?

You didn't answer my question. If, for example, I died instead of Yashur one night, and it turned out that I had a peaceful, cute, and unrecruited role, would you blame Yashur?

How about suggesting the correct one?

I'll suggest it as soon as I find it.

I like the solution.

^
But pay attention to Hec, haha.)
Execute the Shaman.

You didn't answer my question. If, for example, I died instead of Yashur one night, and it turned out that I had a peaceful, cute, and unrecruited role, would you still blame Yashur?

Possibly. At the very least, it would be worth seeing his reaction to the accusations.

Okay, that makes sense, the issue is resolved.

Freedom, Independence, 1998 - Armageddon - Michael Bay - Pearl Harbor - Hawaii - Maui (KindShaman)

:smile20:
Execute the Shaman.

I don't like Mент with his weird voices. Now I'm hesitant to vote for Shaman because of him.

I don't like the voice acting for the Warlock; the voices are too eccentric. Now I'm hesitant to vote for the Shaman because of it.

This is exactly what I was aiming for, muahaha.

Freedom, Independence, 1998 - Cards, money, two guns - United Kingdom - Jamaica Independence (Dag)

Why not like this instead?

Cop, you voted very strangely yesterday. You continue to do so today. You are either Bob, playing a role, or a checker, or a member of the Mafia.

I don't like Cop's strange votes. I'm now hesitant to vote for Shaman because of him.

Kosha, don't reveal the teammate.

Well, if he suddenly turns out to be a city-dwelling type, it's not ideal to have him as a teammate.

Another night before the fifth day has passed. I tend to think this way: we have two days left, Rick is gone, both mafia bosses are still alive, and there's still a maniac wandering around, possibly not even infected. If we don't eliminate at least one of the owners of the Doomsday ultimate, the city is doomed, without a doubt. If we stall and do nothing, the outcome will be the same. Therefore, we need to hang someone. The current candidates are:
Alex.
Hekasan.
Shaman.
Their inactivity is working against all of them. However, Hekasan is writing something like, "Leave me alone, GM, I don't miss a day." Either he has real-life issues, or he's just lurking in the mafia chat, like he did in game 89. He was posting similarly strange things back then. But for now, we only have psychology to go on.

Things are looking a bit better with the Shaman. At least there's some evidence. It seems like a reasonable solution, the only thing that bothers me is the not-so-strong connection. But the Master said that all the evidence would have a clear connection.

I still like Alex-Eagle the most. There are four points against him:
1) Psychology (everyone looks suspicious, they just differ in nuance).
2) Probabilities. There are fewer possible players for Jen Lee (around 5-6) than for Kane (a lot, I didn't even count), so the chances of hitting the right target are higher.
3) The same evidence. It's a bit more complicated here. Both pieces of evidence seem plausible at first glance, and in both cases, the connection between the author and the work is not very strong. But if Armageddon is a standalone movie, then Conan is a hero from an entire series of works by Howard. It's like Poirot or Miss Marple in Agatha Christie - the connection is on an associative level. So, in this respect, the solution for Alex is better.
4) Priority. When there are only two days left until the fifth night, and the city has no protection against the all-consuming ultimates of the mafia, it is obviously more logical to hang the supposed boss, not a puppet. Considering how many times there have been no neutral roles on the negative side, I am almost certain that the protection has been removed from both Zero and Jen Lee.

I'm also very concerned that Alex has been under suspicion for the second day, and he doesn't seem to care. Either he's following the classic rules of role distribution in a mafia group (the boss is quiet), or he's busy (since the beginning of the game!!!). In any case, the fact that he's peaceful seems less and less likely. The Shaman is promising to look into something, to refute it. We need to check that out.
Execute Alexeagle for now. But I won't be surprised if two or all of the listed ones turn out to be bad guys. And that's a long post.