Posts from Мафия 68. The Witcher II

Neyra, is tomorrow, the day you promised to actively engage with the topic, already here?

Not quite. I need to finish my term paper first. I would love to read what's happening here, but I'm really pressed for time.

Arandor, Lord, Sesham, will you comment on the solution? In your opinion, who is better suited for the role of the maniac - Sesham or Alex?

Of course, Alex is a better fit.

Well, the evidence against Alex looks pretty solid too.

1. With his absence?
2. A draw and an analysis of Arandor's execution is better information than another vote dump in the last minutes, when it's hard to tell who is right and who is wrong.
3. And that would be interesting. Do you know who the Mafia are, so you can identify their candidates? And are you sure that those present would quickly agree to execute someone random? And 777 was already nominated for execution, and there were some arguments against him - the focus was on him. A very convenient target.
4. Lol, the Mafia has an extra kill. As long as AR is alive, more useful people and roles will die. And sooner or later, the Mafia will do -2 instead of -1.

1. I read the thread about 777, but he didn't really say anything to us. That's what I wrote about. He wasn't there, he wasn't there... And then he shows up and votes. Look at how he presented his vote. Maybe it's normal for you, but not for me. + On top of that, he voted for Arandor. Do you think Arandor was just voted out by the townspeople? Did the Mafia sit on the sidelines? Did they prefer not to vote at all? I had a different opinion. And yes, he wasn't liked by just me. So his strange behavior isn't just my imagination, but a real fact. Well, that's roughly what I was thinking.
2. No. If there's a chance to execute a Mafia member, you should try, not start a No Night Vote. It's useless.
3. ... Hostor. Turn off your hatred. You have to explain everything... Okay. Do you understand that I know I'm a town member? Of the other 100% town members, it's Vesper. That's it. I don't want to trust anyone else with the execution. It would have been easy for the Mafia to name their candidate for execution and lead others.
4. Sesama has already answered you. There will be someone to trust tomorrow. But not yet. You won't agree with that. Because it's Arandor.) Try to turn off your personal feelings towards people during the game.

Added 3 minutes ago
Yeah. I like her more too. Then you can't consider Sesama a serial killer anymore. She'll be a town member. Because she wouldn't shoot Vesper.
And... Then it turns out:
Neira
Kassi
Mestiar
Dag
Alex (Mafia?)
Lord
Mona
Nebo
There are three Mafia members here.

Did everyone leave?
Okay, let's each write down the characteristics based on this list. Or, at least, choose who seems okay and who seems suspicious.
Neyra. ++/- I'm more inclined to believe her than not. She didn't even vote. Maybe she really didn't have time.
Kassi. --/+ I don't like that she leaves very few posts, but they are... well-thought-out. She understands everything, doesn't ask anyone any questions.
Mestiar ++/- I don't like that she only focused on Arandor. I do like that she picked up on the Lord.
Dag - Let someone else characterize him. I don't see him as peaceful.
Lord. --- He doesn't see Arandor's hints about the role, but he understands who was killed. He's going to be hanged tomorrow.
Mona. --/+ She didn't vote until the very end. She was holding back her vote for some reason... then she disappeared. There are no candidates from her. Only talk about how she doesn't want Ara, doesn't want Sezam, but what to do...
Nebo. ++/- I like that he was looking for clues. I like his reaction to Arandor's execution. I just don't remember his trust/distrust throughout the game.
And I have... Kassi, Dag (unclear), Lord, Mona.

So... it turns out:
Neyra
Kassi
Mestiar
Dag (Hos)
Alex (mage?)
Lord
Mona
Sky
There are three mages here.

x) .

What? That’s easier for me. Half are Mirki players, half are mafia players. Choose whichever.

I was just thinking that jasmine and the scent of jasmine are two different things, and I decided to look further into it.
So, here's what I found: Alex has a quote from the novel "Demian, Story of a Youth" by Emil Sinclair in his signature. Sinclair is a pseudonym for Hermann Hesse, and Hesse has a work called "The Scent of Jasmine"... http://nano.fantlab.ru/work101804

:smile05:

Added 4 minutes later
I was searching for it, but I didn't find anything, I'm getting old...

What? Oh no, you don't like the solution, or do you think Alex is harmless? ))

He was upset that he wasn't the one who found this clue.

I don't like that I didn't find it myself.

Neira - Neira always plays like this, so it's hard to say who she might be; I don't really see her as Mafia.
Kassi - She left one post and disappeared, just like Alex in that Mafia game, so I'm not a fan.
(Dag)Hos - There's no information about Dag, and Hos is known for his aggressive playstyle, although... (and he also likes Arandor, by the way).
Lord - He figured everything out right away, good job, but he still wanted to execute Ara and me, even though there are plenty of other candidates who look worse.
Mona - After voting for Ara, I see her as Mafia, or maybe she's just not interested in playing. She shows visible activity, but in reality, she's afraid to suggest anything of her own.
Nebo - Well, I have absolutely no idea about Nebo.
Arandor - Understood.
Kits - In some moments, he raises suspicions, in others, he doesn't. Overall, compared to the others, I don't think he's Mafia.
Alex - There's very good evidence against him.

So, it's almost the same as with Kits, but I'm not sure about Nebo. Also, I don't like that Mortulus. Mona raises suspicions. I haven't played with Kassi before, or if I have, I didn't have time to observe her behavior.

As for myself, I'll say that no game is without mistakes. In the case of Arandor, I made a mistake, and that's perfectly normal. Besides, I was the first to talk about Arandor, calling him suspicious and resembling a Mafia member. Isn't that a bit too obvious for a Mafia player? I'm not an idiot to set myself up like that.

I liked this one after the execution:

Could it be Bernard? Will the day end sooner after his turn?

Added after 43 seconds
Okay.

I liked this one after the execution:

Well, I still don't consider him a Mafia member as confidently as the others, I just have some doubts. Although, everyone has doubts here. It won't be interesting at all if the Mafia consists entirely of inactive players.

*the tree gave Haven a bouquet of branches with blue eyes so that Haven wouldn't be upset* )))

I am generally a paranoid creature, and it's difficult for me to say who I suspect more and who less + I can come up with a perfectly logical peaceful explanation for any suspicious behavior... For example, the fact that Lord persistently considered Arandor a mafia member suggests rather his peacefulness; otherwise, he simply wouldn't want to be seen in such a context... Unless, of course, he did it on purpose, counting on such thoughts ))
I think that with my reasoning, I can only confuse things even more, so for now I will just read yours, and closer to the end of the night I will try to make a list of suspected mafia members.