Forum — Tournament Committee

Javdet

13 years ago

Auto-translated

I feel sorry for Valik for some reason... it's not easy for such people in real life.

RomarioGrom

13 years ago

Auto-translated

And what, did Valentin leave us unexpectedly, without having time to enjoy the forum?

Lider1

13 years ago

Auto-translated

kalababa, it just so happens that the "award" for the best town and the season winner can be won by any average player, and even a relative newbie. Therefore, they don't really have any special value. This won't work in a tournament. And no moderator or anyone else has the right to select this award, as it is not stated anywhere that it is forbidden to play with newbies and inflate one's rating on them. And there is no clear definition of who is a newbie and who is not. And "newbie" is a relative concept (depending on who you are playing against).

In reply to Lider1

kalababa

13 years ago

Auto-translated

Lider1

kalababa, it just so happens that the "award" for the best town and the winner of the season can be won by any average player, and even a relative newbie. Therefore, they don't really have any special value. This won't work in a tournament. And no moderator or anyone else has the right to select this award, as it is not stated anywhere that it is forbidden to play with newbies and inflate one's rating on them. And there is no clear definition of who is a newbie and who is not. And "newbie" is a relative concept (depending on who you are playing against).

I won't argue about the value - it's all very individual. Give me an example of when a person received such an award and, in terms of skill, was suitable for a beginner? I don't see any such examples; these awards are given to seasoned veterans of the game. So, the argument is quite weak.

Егор Коробейников

13 years ago

Auto-translated

Let's discuss the newcomer here, guys, everyone come here! I think Dark did a great job. Flux got a medal and went from being in a group to being a favorite! Well done!

In reply to Егор Коробейников

Heroes13

13 years ago

Auto-translated

Yegor Korobeynikov

Let's discuss the newcomer here, guys, everyone come here!!! I think Dark is doing great. He got a medal and went from being in a group to being a favorite! Well done!

And they're taking him as a newcomer? Yeah, right... Not exactly newbies are welcome in the newcomer category, but all fresh players are just clones :D

Snooppy

13 years ago

Auto-translated

kalababa

Give me an example of when someone received such an award and also had the skills suitable for a beginner. I don't see any such cases; these awards are given to seasoned veterans of the game. So, the argument is quite weak.

Before the Winter Newcomer competition in 2012, if I remember correctly, Browser, I think, won the award for best player in the Citadel category, and there was a lot of talk about it... In the end, he didn't even leave the group. So, it's not a good indicator, in my opinion...

Captain

13 years ago

Auto-translated

twaryna

Reducing the number of battles per day due to the timer is a simplification and a degradation.

On the contrary, we have degraded with such unlimited battles. In the interportal, ХВ lost to almost all foreigners, not only to the fast-playing Chinese, but even to the Poles and the "slow" Balts ;)

And they already said that before, HL+U players used to play for 4 minutes, and those players wouldn't win against the current ones.
And phrases like "I want to defeat Maretti, no matter what"... are bad :(

Oelm

When some Vik participated in tournaments with SOD players, he often tried to force them to use the TE version.
...
He did it out of love...

Honey, do you have a child with Vik? Did he still force you and then fall in love with you? ;)
Seriously, you, Oelm aka Indra, have never participated in any personal club tournament, and Vik was a judge in all of them. And even in Kyiv - the 1st CIS tournament - he didn't favor anyone with TE. We played on 4 versions, whoever wanted to.

Sevensan

13 years ago

Auto-translated

yeah, dark noob. just ignore it. =)

ariputra

13 years ago

Auto-translated

I see the situation as follows: almost everyone has had or still has the desire to create a clone and participate in the beginner tournament. Some people gave in to their desire, while others suppressed it, but the aftertaste inevitably remains for some time.

But, overall, I'm not against clones. If a person really wants to do this, and they are not allowed, which essentially provokes and pushes them to commit a "crime" (creating a clone), then no one removes the blame from them. What else can they do? The desire remains (and it's not that easy to get rid of it), so let them participate, even if they are significantly stronger. That will make it more interesting.

Lim4

13 years ago

Auto-translated

It’s a pity you can’t read the deleted messages (they were deleted for a reason). You could burst with curiosity!:smile50:

VanjaM

13 years ago

Auto-translated

I think you can play the beginner campaign only once, not more.

Lim4

13 years ago

Auto-translated

ariputra, where is my money and helicopter?:smile07:

Lider1

13 years ago

Auto-translated

Oelm

Navukh, you should take advantage of the fact that you live far away, you scumbag, brave internet warrior. If you said this to me in person, it's not a given that you would live long.

What prevents you from coming to the tournament and looking Navukh in the face? :D