Posts from Mafia 47. Battle of Movie Heroes

Even without excessive chatter, we can still achieve a good result. Not everyone has responded yet.

Yes, I hope more people will share their opinions. It would be interesting to hear what Zubr has to say as well.

LET'S GO, BATTHERT HOSTORU!!

Added 3 minutes later
By the way, that's funny. 6 nights, the end of the game, and there are still 9 players alive, almost half.

They just banned the mapper. x)

I just think the ending came a bit too early. Things could have unfolded completely differently. I even thought you guys decided to write the finale as if it were a Mafia game. Tox seems to think so too.

I don't have much to add. Tox and Arandor played well. Siever did a good job. Gur was impressive. Overall, the game was better than the last one. The Mafia was very obvious. There was only one inconsistency – I thought Koshu was Mafia, not Siever. P.S. I decided about the Mafia right after the "What" execution. It was very obvious. Spir – well done. The idea with the Saw made people much more active, and overall, everything went smoothly on his part. The clue about Jack doesn't count – they executed "What" based on it anyway. By the way, about the clues – they were the most optimal compared to the previous games. Not easy, but solvable, and they give the Mafia the opportunity to frame other players (it's strange that they only started doing this towards the end). Thanks to everyone for the game.

Finally got around to this topic:)
Thanks to everyone for the game, we put up a good fight :)
Special apologies to Rudoy for deciding to eliminate him (although he deserved it, given his role:)). He was the only peaceful player who could put significant pressure on me during the day.
I enjoyed the games of Siver (he should have been given the decisions for the nighttime actions :)), Ment (except for the riddle about Tox, everything else was done excellently), Arandor (he really got into it towards the end, reminding me of himself in those best games of yours that I've seen), Gur (surprisingly, he was very good at gathering information).
I can't really single out anyone else:o
I'll write separately about Tox. He seemed to be actively playing, doing a lot of analysis and searching for clues, but his excessive zeal without considering all the options specifically in this game led him to essentially play as a member of the mafia (the only thing that mitigates this is the fact that he accidentally executed Chto? during the day). But either way, it's better to play like that than to make one move per day.

I want to share one thought regarding the rules of the games.
All questions about the game mechanics should be asked before the start of the first day. Otherwise, it happens again and again that when the mafia tries to deceive the town and somehow twist the action of one or another nighttime role, the town immediately runs to the GM, and the mafia's plan fails. Therefore, it would be good to clarify all the nuances before the start of the game, and for the GMs to clearly define them.

P.S. Gur, I won't challenge you to a duel; millionaires from Metropolis don't have a conscience:)

The Mafia was giving themselves away.

Don't forget, we needed to give Pile a hint.

Zubr, were you playing Mafia? How did I help you? =)

Zubr, were you playing the mafia game? How did I help you? =)

You were constantly attacking the wrong people. For example, if the serial killer hadn't been executed, I'm almost certain that Arandor would have been easily executed. They would have just supported you, and that would have been it. Mortulus could also have been executed.
+ It's much easier to hide behind you. You don't have to take the lead, or campaign - you'll do all of that yourself.

My apologies to the redhead for deciding to kill him.

Nah, it's just a game.

Nevertheless, Arko convinced me of his peaceful nature, and I wouldn't have executed him. But I could have executed Lord. Thanks, Guru, for convincing me on the fourth day that he was peaceful. In general, it's pointless to argue about what could have been. We played the way we played.

However, Arko convinced me of his peaceful nature, and I wouldn't have executed him. But I could have executed Lord. Thanks, Guru, for convincing me on the fourth day that he was peaceful.
But in general, it's pointless to argue about what could have been. We played the way we played.

I'm not arguing:) You asked, and I answered.

By the way, Zubr, I hope we get to play on the same team at least once. x) I don't remember if that's ever happened.

And here's a post that breaks the record, heh.

By the way, I liked the GIFs. I don't understand why everyone is so critical of them.