Posts from Batman: Arkham city

But the mafia will be completely exposed.

Amko might not have read the thread and just cast his vote randomly. I don't see him trying to curry favor here. And Amko's later posts are quite good and contain an analysis of the situation.

Which means they can't say anything because of the move. That's good, right? Even better than letting inactive players lose.

he just doesn't like you.

because you acted according to your principles.

most likely he found something negative.

What if he's a cop, not a suicide bomber?

But he wrote something else later. He could have changed his voice. And I still don't really like his posts. I've seen better games from Amko.

Well, Amko can clearly access the forum. And Gumer will just keep quiet later, when all the problems are solved.

Anyway, Hossi, Arandor hasn't been playing with interest lately. And he doesn't really like psychological games, as he has already said.

You're just being stubborn as always. I know you're often right, but you forget that you also make mistakes.

I know you're eliminating Arandor mostly because you just don't like him.

But right now, we've lost too many town roles, and if he's a cop or a suicide bomber, we're definitely going to lose, all because you acted according to your principles.

In any case, try to ignore your antipathies and execute Amko instead. Or listen to Aru. If he's really a cop, he probably found some negative information, and that can't be ignored.

In the end, at least trust my intuition =[/QUOTE]
Why should I trust someone who, instead of restoring an analytical post, writes nonsense that is more suitable for the Mafia?

He's not selfish, unlike you. Others are selfish, but he isn't.

My actions are logical and aimed at gaining profit for the town. If you don't like it, Mafia? That's your problem.

Hossi, what do you think, who did the Mafia save today?

Someone whose saving would be unexpected in case of execution. Something like Plesen/Links/Neyra/Gumer. Moreover, saving a townie can have a double benefit - the Cop knows exactly who to kill and leaks the information, and the Mafia sits without a loss.
If this subtle hint "olololo, if I were Mafia, I would be saved, don't bother executing" doesn't work. First, it's a sign of desperation. Second, you were under the Cop's radar, who would hardly have exposed you during the day, finishing the job at night. Actually, you just got lucky that Matilda was the Cop. And that's it

which is being exposed by the mafia.

"Arandor is the cop and found something negative." Hmm. The most likely scenario being considered: the mafia killed, the serial killer is blocked. Serial killer. Not the mafia. The town has no doctor and is in a coma. The cop is being exposed and suggests executing the serial killer. This is a severe case of brain malfunction. The serial killer now needs to kill at least one mafia member for balance, regardless of the execution. Instead, the serial killer goes to the guillotine. At night, the cop dies. The mafia manipulates the vote, thanks to the loss of votes and the lawyer. Amen? If Arandor were the cop, he would have doomed the town to lose with such a stupid move.

If this subtle hint "lol, if I were the mafia, I would be cleared, don't bother executing me" doesn't work.

I don't understand why I should switch my vote from a player who is negative for me to a player whose negativity is close to zero compared to the first. Why should I trust him?

Arandor has no one in the negative roles except Amko.

And he advocates for the execution because Amko is having fun.

First, he says he has an amazing role and everyone is doomed without him, then he gets executed and doesn't reveal himself, then when it's time to reveal himself because he's really about to be executed, he backs down, hiding behind his mysterious role. I'll rephrase it as a question: Will an awesome town role scare the town by not revealing itself on the scaffold?
Arandor has no one in the negative roles except Amko. And he advocates for the execution because Amko is having fun. In short, there's no investigation. A great argument in the spirit of "well, Amko is probably Mafia..."
Plus, he loses his vote and disappears. A town role would never let things go on like that.

And the cop, even though he had two successful night investigations, albeit with a 50/50 chance, would have revealed himself if he had been nominated for execution.

1. Why is the player killed when they are clearly a Town member, and not Mafia? There's no need to bring up the "bloody" aspect. Also, it's possible that protection was activated instead of a block.

2. If you remain silent and allow the Town member to be executed, is the town not doomed? :)

You accuse, you don't believe, you push for an analysis, and then I'm to blame (if there's no analysis, I'm still to blame). This is a terrible way to play. It's just excuses and poor skill.

You should execute a random player, hoping that they are Mafia.

It's a pity, I was already going to defend myself and give an example of another Mafia game where everyone defended themselves every night. But no, it's better to defend an innocent person and lose the Night Defense than to defend a suspect and extend their life until the night. But no, this Night Defense is needed for other purposes, right? :)

Do we still have Town members left?

Or pause the game until everyone can be present here.

Because a person who executed the Mafia member was deliberately killed. A **maniac wouldn't eliminate an active player** who is involved in analyzing and searching for the Mafia. And the problem with protection is precisely because of the bloodshed. Unfortunately.

Are you a cop? Seriously? I haven't seen an autopsy. During an autopsy, they discuss actions during the night, motives, and analyze their moves. You haven't done any of that, "cop."

So, are you a cop or a protected Mafia member? X)

Because a person who executed the Mafia member was deliberately killed. A maniac wouldn't eliminate an active player who is analyzing and searching for the Mafia. And the problem with protection is precisely because of the bloodshed. Unfortunately.

my vote is with you. Analysis? If I want to, I'll do it. I don't believe in Mafia reveals from day one, so I go by INTUITION or whatever else I have.
I shouldn't reveal myself!!1

lol. If anyone has a better chance of exposing the Mafia, it's me. I already wrote a list of suspects.

But you already gave yourself away.

I'm too lazy to look it up. Do me a favor and remind me.