Posts from Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

A good idea to have 10-15 games. If someone wants to play, they can join a seasonal tournament. But it's best not to include players with only 1 post on the forums and who are unknown on other resources in tournaments.

For your information: each participant was checked and had previously played somewhere, or someone vouched for them. Katherine, by the way, is from a group on VKontakte, so please express any remaining emotions in the discussion forum.

Indeed. Stop scolding me, I just wanted to have a little fun.

What a scoundrel xD I thought I had found the girl of my dreams, but she's cheating here, oh dear...
Dirty_Player, for example, I didn't play anywhere before the Novice-2011-Summer tournament. I mean, I didn't play ANYWHERE, just at home on my computer + I watched replays/streams/analyzed various saves. And I took top-3 in the tournament. And only then did I start playing actively with people. And if they had set a condition for me - 10-15 reports, then I could participate in the tournament - I would have continued to just watch, 100% I guarantee it. And I'm sure I'm not the only one.
Cheating, in my opinion, is not such a widespread phenomenon that it requires preventive measures. Sufficient punitive sanctions are enough...

What a scoundrel xD I thought I had found the girl of my dreams, and she's here cheating, oh dear...
Dirty_Player, for example, I didn't play anywhere before the Novice-2011-Summer tournament. I mean, I didn't play ANYWHERE, just at home on my computer + I watched replays/streams/analyzed saves. And I took top-3 in the tournament. And only then did I start playing actively with people. And if they had set a condition for me - 10-15 reports, then I could participate in the tournament - I would have continued to just watch, 100% I guarantee it. And I'm sure I'm not the only one.

But don't confuse the Novice tournament with other tournaments. Of course, this rule shouldn't apply to the Novice tournament. After 15 games, you can already outgrow it :)

Indeed. Stop scolding me, can't I have a little fun?

Have fun with fun matches... Tournament games are not for cheaters. You only ruined the tournament spirit...

punish Katya severely!)) hahaha

As many already know, a week ago the game save from Katherine vs Volodymyr in the Jebus Cross tournament was submitted to the AC: 2:

/topic/at/546732/

and player Katherine was accused of cheating.

A detailed analysis of the first day was made, and a superficial one for 5 days; they didn't look any further, as it was clear enough and sufficient.

Analysis.

111
Regarding resources:
Resources gathered - 9 stone, 5 mercury.
Resources spent - 5 stone, 10 wood, 15000 gold (1000 wolf den, 900 wolves, 600 goblins, 2500x5 heroes, 2000x2 skills at the university, 1000 purchase +1 attack).
Remaining: 0 wood, 9 mercury, 14 stone, 4 sulfur, 4 crystal, 4 gems, 700 gold.
In total, we see that the balance regarding money is off by 5700.

Regarding experience:
Kreg kills 18 liches (30x18=540), takes Pandora for 10000, initially has 62.
Total: 10602.
In the end, he has 10902.
The experience balance is off by 300 units.

In the battle with the liches, they are somehow killed without any losses to the wolves, with only a few goblins remaining and no participation from the elementals in the battle.
/ I managed to defeat them on the first try, taking everyone into the battle. Kreg came out with 1 water elemental and 14 goblins./
It is impossible to conduct a battle with these final losses, even if all of Kreg's stacks were demoralized twice per round ).

112 - another questionable battle; elves are killed with a group stack without any losses to the wolves. And at the same time, gremlins, which are much weaker and stand in the way, are ignored... Also, Kreg received more than 2000 extra experience from somewhere.
113 - Kreg gained almost 2000 more experience out of thin air (chests were, of course, taken into account).
114 - almost 2000 more experience of unclear origin.
115 - something seems suspicious about being able to lose so little when defeating two hives. Especially the first one, which Adel takes.
/ I didn't really try hard, but I lost everything except for a few wolves in it./

This is a quick analysis. No one wants to look further because they clearly cheat on every turn...

Conclusion
Player Katherine demonstrates excellent knowledge of cheat codes and great skill in using them in practice.

Decision
Award player Katherine with the Black Mark of a Cheater, and a request will be sent to the Creator to this effect. Also, Katherine will be added to the blacklist with a warning to players and tournament organizers about possible cheating.

The decision was made unanimously by four members of the AC who participated in analyzing the saves.

Just like in Harry Potter, a dark mark.

Just like in Harry Potter, a dark mark!

Indeed, it's quite amusing...
Some of our female users receive flowers under their avatars for March 8th, while others are given a Dark Mark...
Don't you feel the difference? Or maybe you're on the wrong forum?

Well, everywhere there are "good" and "bad" sides.

I haven't encountered such cheaters before; not only is it a girl (although that's not certain), but she also doesn't deny the fact that she's cheating:eek:

Kind of like a girl, huh? It seems like everyone has already forgotten about Jed.

It was a girl, I assure you. I'm not denying that I couldn't resist. It won't happen again. P.s. You should learn yourselves on the forum, and then you'll be unhappy that someone is trying it out).

I'm telling you, she's a girl. I won't deny it, I couldn't help myself. It won't happen again. P.s. you should learn yourselves on the forum, and then complain that someone is trying it)

Based on these considerations, if they constantly show all sorts of maniacs on TV, dismembering girls, with all the details, then it means you definitely need to try dismembering some girl yourself.:smile03:
I want to believe in your sincere repentance and request for conditional early release... although a relapse is not ruled out.:smile36: