Auto-translated
Spir, the thing is, one of us is 100% a Town member, because his role isn't mentioned in the newspaper. =)
Do you want me to calculate the probability for the remaining two? Sure.
If we take the worst-case scenario and assume 5 against 8 (let's also include the Mafia), it will be like this:
For each role of one player, there are 12 roles of another player.
If the first one is a Town member, then in 4 out of 12 cases, the second one is also a Town member. We multiply this by the number of possible Town roles. In total, it's 20 out of 60.
If the first one is a Mafia member, then in 5 out of 12 cases, the second one is a Town member. We multiply this by the number of possible Evil roles. In total, it's 40 out of 96.
Overall, it's 60 out of 156. In percentage terms, it's 38% that all three are Town members. Not that small.
Besides, I'm starting to think that's the case, and the real Mafia members are quietly laughing, watching Spir and me accuse each other.