Posts from Мафия 32. Asylum

because personally, I really like the setting we're playing in right now

That's the right clarification; otherwise, it's all about the mafia, but the GM is much more dangerous in any scenario.

Execute Hostor.
I won't even comment on anything else, because it's pointless.

And yes, from the perspective of pure gameplay, "Mafia" has lost its essence.

Here, I agree. While new features are good, a game where the town team has virtually no chance is a complete nightmare. I have never been against having two Mafia teams, but even with that, it's much harder for the town to decide who to execute, which leads to nonsense like this.

Yes, the setting is very good and interesting, but in it, the outcome of the game for the town mainly depends on the first night, and that's not a good thing.
I also don't like the overpowered role of the serial killer, who is very unlikely to be executed at all. Why should the town waste a vote on him if he doesn't bother anyone except the psychos? And the psychos will never kill him because he will simply either hide or lie in wait and kill, and no night action except the first one affects him. What kind of imbalance is this? The serial killer should either win alone or, like "Mr. Death," win by being the last one standing against one team (he'll kill everyone and go home to drink tea with cookies). In general, there is no balance with the serial killer role.

And in general, since when do players have to work for the setting? Yes, from a logical point of view, it would be correct if the good doctors continue to treat the psychos and none of them die. Yes, it would be nice if the cop helps the good/evil doctors get rid of the psychos and competitors and becomes a good/corrupt cop. Of course, from a literary point of view, such scenarios would have a great ending; I'm sure Slonysh will write it well, and there definitely won't be any flying horseshoes. However, such a game in itself loses its flavor. Initially, everything should be like this: the town's goal is to get rid of all the Mafia and serial killers, the Mafia's goal is to remain one, and the serial killer's goal is to kill everyone and not get caught. And all these "do you want non-standard situations? I have them!" are nonsense and take away all the meaning of the game. I've said everything.

P.S. Yes, by the way, I'm still against recruiting Mafia members; it's time to stop this.

Let me see what's going on here... For now, we'll execute Hostor, but if he's not Radonar, we won't execute him. :(

Added 55 minutes later

Looks like the psychics are smarter than the city...

What can you do? :(

If I understand correctly, we currently have 1 mafia, 4 psychics, 3 bad doctors, and 7 good doctors. In this situation, it doesn't really matter which mafia member to eliminate. Considering the short-term alliance prospects between humanists and psychics, there's a reason to eliminate Vistrit. However, we need to be cautious with these psychics. I'm ready to change my vote if necessary.

What are the intermediate results of the vote?

Intermediate results: Execute Hostor - 8 (Reinhard, Nebo, RiMpel2, WhiteLizard, Werevolka, Gur, WisTrit, Hermit) Execute WisTrit - 5 (Gil4, Xostor, WishmasteR, Kniaz_OMEGA) 8 votes are needed for execution, so Hostor is basically done for. Psychos, if you want to ally with us, you can see who is shouting the loudest; just kill Reinhard already. But Gil (if you're a guard, of course), don't go after him; it's not nice to kill your own.

Added after 3 minutes
P.S. If we're going to take risks, we're going to take risks; I won't regret anything about Revanke.

Choose me, choose me, Rodfield Longshanks, the leader of tomorrow!

How about instead of execution, we give the psychos some candy, and they, in return, will eliminate all the evil doctors in one night, and then everyone wins!

I'll take my share with a couple of cups of coffee.

If Hossi Ranodar is present, the city has a good chance of winning...
I'll take the risk...
Execute Hostor

On the one hand, executing Hosa might be beneficial, but on the other... the psychomages will turn against us and kill everyone indiscriminately. =(
Therefore, execute Vistrit, because I consider him a villain.

They’ll kill us all anyway, just later. And we’re not executing Hostor if he isn’t Radonar.

They'll kill us all anyway, just later. And we're not executing Hostor if he isn't Radonar.

Maybe in that case, it's worth taking a risk and choosing a different option? Maybe he'll turn out to be more capable? What about Hermit, Lorelei?

Don't trust Hostor, gentlemen, don't trust him...

Sincerely,
Gur

Don't trust Hostor, gentlemen, don't trust him...

Or he will eat you all!

Sincerely,
Hostor