Posts from Mafia 31. Twilight Dances. Auto-translated

Which came first: the Knight's Noble Deed selection, or the Duke's target assignment?

The main thing is that Torii can be trusted because he is not a mafia member or a maniac, and besides, they wouldn't be able to kill him with disks.

And what came first: the Knight's choice of a Noble Deed, or the Duke assigning a target?

Without a target, the Knight doesn't move at all.

That’s right.

So, what should we do now? There are no murders, and no clues, except for the knight's. We can lock him up in jail to keep him from causing more trouble, and then release him somehow later. What a way to ruin a good night.

Hmm...
I was blocked by Whisper. Mafia Night Action #1.
I was protected by Warden. Thank you.
A Crippling Arrow (Archer) was used on Hosa. Mafia Night Action #2.
Zedzi... It seems he was visited by a Technomancer. I assume the sound of breaking glass means another Night Action, but I don't understand which one.
A Thief stole a random Night Action from Arandor for two nights.
Toria killed the Moon Dancer. Mafia Night Action #3 - the last one. I don't see any clues; it seems "Gleam" was used.
After that, Toria's status was checked by the Alchemist.
And then the Witch made the best move of the night - she resurrected the poor guy. I think everyone will agree that we now have a guaranteed town member. It's funny, because it was Toria who made me a town member on the first night of Mafia game #28.
And the worst move of the night - the Knight killed Hermit.

All Mafia Night Actions have been used.
There is no mana for a move.
I don't see the "Angel's Step". I don't see the Golem's protection. I don't see the Abbot's protection. I don't see the Advisor's "Observer". I don't see the Governor's "Vigilant Guards".

So, there is an unknown action left with Ara. Angel's Step - I don't think so. Vigilant Guards also seem unlikely, in my opinion, based on this description. So, it's either protection/check by the Abbot, or Golem's protection, or the Advisor's "Observer". In the third option, the only thing that worries me is that the "Observer" should be watching, not guarding the house, in theory. But I can't guarantee it.

Questions for the Game Master:
1. If a Night Action fails after the Crippling Arrow, is the Night Action not displayed in the newspaper at all?
2. If an attempt is made to kill the Angel, would the newspaper show an assassination attempt?
3. If "jamming" is used against the Technomancer, is it possible that the Night Action will not be displayed at all?

For now, I'll leave it at this stage of analyzing the night events; conclusions will be later.

Gil - block from Whisper + protection from the Guard Captain.
Gil, from now on, get better quality herbs...
Hostor - crippling shot from the Archer.
Come on, 15 cm diagonally upwards, and I would have left you.
Zedzi - static field from the Technomancer.
Someone got bad grades at the techno-academy...
Arandor - steal from the Thief and observe from the Advisor.
If Archie's "Sesame Street" collection was stolen, I don't envy the thief... and the observer is a noob, he missed the Thief.
Thorium - kill from the Dancer, drop from the Alchemist, heal from the Witch
Damn, dude, I'm glad you survived! :D
Hermit - kill from the Knight.
A Knight with a killing spree... +1 maniac?

Wow, the doctor walked so well!

Sky was upset...

Three people came to Gil.

Who was the third?

Were they trying to frame or whitewash Hostor, claiming he wasn't the Mafia?

Or they just wanted to block him. We will learn about the true goals as the analytical actions develop.

Hostor was walking home with a bathtub - it seems to be a reference to some of the "boss" roles, like the Governor or the Advisor.

HAHAHA, I have a bathtub at home! I'm cool!

There are no kills from Mana, so the victim was protected - this is Gil or Ar.

They should describe the protection. Block or skip the night.

Someone didn't like Hermit.
someone could have taken a risk.
someone doesn't care about the game.

Here are three possible reasons for Hermit's murder) and to all three, you can add Stupidity, even if Hermit was the Mafia, but that's unlikely. Elves don't sit in taverns.

Arandor is a Knight and isn't being exposed. :D

Added 2 minutes ago

The Moon Dancer killed Thorium. Mafia's night kill #3 - the last one. I don't see any clues, it seems that "Gleam" worked.

There are no clues for unsuccessful kills

who is the third?

there were sounds
then voices
and the guards stood
total: 3 people

I didn't want to read anyone else's theories to avoid getting confused. Here's my take on the events:
The Whisperer and the Head of the Guard visited Gil.
Hostora was shot by the Archer with a crippling arrow.
Zedzi was visited by the Technomage.
A thief and an advisor visited Arandor.
The most popular character is Thor, who was visited by the Moon Dancer, the Alchemist, and the Witch.
It's unclear who killed Hermit. It doesn't seem like something a serial killer would do, and the mafia usually doesn't kill twice. Or do they?
I think Hermit was the viceroy.

So, what do we do now? There are no murders.

I think Hermit will be very surprised by this fact, Archie.

P.S. Hooray, I read Gil and Hostora's theories, and they think the same way!! (or almost the same way) :)

I would describe the defense. Block or skip turn.

I'm leaning towards the fact that the maniac skipped his turn.

I think Hermit will be very surprised by this fact, Archie.

There are no kills from the villains. Is that clearer?

Guys.

What was earlier: choosing a Knight as a Neutral Defender, or assigning a target with a Duke?

Assigning a target with a Duke.

The Sorceress comes to the guy even if he has a defense that triggers and he would have survived without her.

Toria, the dancer, didn't kill.

I don't see "Angel's Step".

It's silent, not displayed.

I don't see the "Observer" of the Advisor. I don't see the "Vigilant Guards" of the Governor.

It's not displayed.

Questions from Gila#

1. In general
2. Yes
3. It depends on what kind of Neutral Defender it is. Displayed ones are always displayed.

Didn't even have time to log in, and already a couple of pages are filled with irrelevant posts. They should take pity on new players.

The Healer did a good job! His intuition is excellent.

There are no kills from villains. Is that clearer?

I just quoted your words.

there were sounds
then voices
and the guards stood
total: 3 people

relate it to the role, prove the theory, earn a plus in the database.

Yema, why didn't you just say that these non-player characters aren't displayed?

Hoshi, with Visa's post, I'm retracting my assumption.

So, in that case, it turns out that a thief and a golem visited me, since other non-player characters aren't displayed.

Maybe I just forgot to describe it and now I'm trying to make excuses!