Auto-translated
The wealthy have mistresses, we have girlfriends.
Kash
Posts from Forum
Kash
Wicc
Auto-translated
Did you serve in the army, kid?
If you're talking about dictatorship and one-man judging, then there's a much higher chance of corruption in judging.
A judge is a very vulnerable figure; if they get involved in something like that, players will simply stop signing up for Tournaments, and at best, they'll all leave the current one immediately.
Besides, in this case, to embody the principle of "the law is the same for everyone," the judge must have a strong character; otherwise, even if they catch someone cheating, they won't be able to penalize them.
Remember Vitalik's case; Neo initially had a very weak position – he was not only the judge but also the injured party, Vitalik's opponent in the final. That's where there was plenty of room for gossip and speculation with almost any decision.
However, he handled the situation with dignity. I'm even afraid to imagine what the Arbitration Committee would have done... Vitalik had a very strong support group, and the situation was also not 100% clear.
Catch
Auto-translated
I, for example, wouldn't make a decision about the Clash of Heroes tournament alone.
In the end, the decision was made to withdraw from the tournament, and this is entirely within the competence of the host. :)
If you haven't gotten tired yet, continue to criticize the system. It hasn't even been properly tested yet; it needs to be tested and refined, but you...
That's what I'm saying, the system is imperfect, and an AK (Administration Committee) isn't needed. ;) But I'm always ready to help discuss something. ;)
LeBron
Auto-translated
Pash, stop arguing like that, it's not working for you. You're a tight player, they're aggressive. Your strength lies in AA, KK, and AK :cool:
Man, I can't help but make fun of you guys.
Enough already. It's like a kindergarten, honestly.
This is just a continuation of the poker topic...
"Это нам идеально подходит!" [Новосибирск, 2013]
"Красавчик! Если только не читер.." [Киев, 2014]
"Это Вам не шутки - нажрался Dust в маршрутке" [Новокузнецк, 2015]
Сам ты фиш (с) :D
Kash
Auto-translated
How about we pit Ketch and Vik against each other and watch them battle with D3 and G2? :smile04:
Catch
Auto-translated
How about we pit Ketch and Vik against each other and watch them battle with D3 and G2? :smile04:
Your "pit them against each other" skills haven't improved much :D
Kash
Auto-translated
Your "natravlyalka" hasn't grown :D
General ZeT
Auto-translated
I am not afraid to take responsibility, but I want the decision to be well-considered, correct, and qualified, which is why the Arbitration Committee (AC) was handling this situation. If there were no AC, I would have made the decision myself, of course.
One mind is good, but two are better.
...let's take a look at something we will never know, but with common sense, we can assume. Let's say Alex's case was not referred to the AC, and the judge, within reasonable limits, made a certain decision (the AC's decision would be one of the possible outcomes), and some users would not like it. What would happen then? Ask yourselves, esteemed disgruntled users.
Moreover, because of two or more players, the established AC organization could not have stopped its work and the authority to make decisions, because it was created for these purposes.
:smile17:
PReDS
Auto-translated
...
Especially considering two or more players, the officially established AK organization could not halt its operations and the authority to make decisions, as it was created for these purposes...
SEM_56
Auto-translated
Regardless, AlexazeGreat was accused not by his opponent, but by a third party (the player on the left). Is this acceptable?
I've been struggling with the rule for weeks: who can file a complaint about unfair play?
The opponent, or anyone who simply didn't like certain actions?
I'm asking you, or are we just going to keep joking around?
I've been struggling with the rule for weeks: who can file a complaint about unfair play?
The opponent, or anyone who simply didn't like certain actions?
I'm asking you, or are we just going to keep joking around?
Ушел с героев, пока пряники)
Дубровин Павел
Auto-translated
Regardless, AlexazeGreat was accused not by his opponent, but by a third party (the player on the left). Is this permissible?
I've been struggling with the rule for weeks: who can file a complaint about unfair play?
The opponent, or anyone who simply didn't like certain actions?
And I'm asking you, or are we just going to keep joking around, comrades?
According to the current AK Regulations:
2. Any user of HW (not necessarily a participant in the game) can also raise suspicions of cheating in the AK (against any of its members) if the match/matches were played on any other resource in any online HOMM3 tournament between HOMM3 players registered on HW.
С истиной где-то рядом...
Лето 2010.
Лето 2010.
Erdem
Auto-translated
Damn, they're comparing each other's "attack dogs" again... What is it with them, it's the same thing every day.
Don't worry, Victor! As is usually the case in such situations: two people will organize a protest, shout in the square, release negative energy, and then they will disperse without achieving anything. You'll see. :)
P.S. I don't think the posts should be deleted, as they serve for social identification of users + free lectures on political science, sociology, psychology, and group dynamics may still be useful to many before the inevitable May exam session. As they say: every cloud has a silver lining. So don't miss the continuation of the lecture today: chapter IV "conspiracy theory". It will be interesting. :)
SEM_56
Auto-translated
According to the current AC Regulations:
2. Also, any HeroesWorld user (not necessarily a game participant) may approach any AC member with suspicions of cheating in the AC, provided that the game/games were played on any other resource in any online HOMM3 tournament between HOMM3 players registered on HeroesWorld.
Okay Pasha, the penny has dropped!!!
Now tell me, can anyone file a complaint if a player, having caught their opponent cheating, has no objections despite seeing it???!!!!:smile12:
Added after 1 minute
Don't worry, Victor! As usual in such situations: 2 people organize a protest, shout in the square, vent negative energy, and then leave empty-handed themselves. You'll see. :)
P.S. IMO, posts shouldn't be deleted for social identification of users + free lectures on political science, sociology, psychology, and TLP might still come in handy for many before the inevitably approaching May exam session. As they say: every cloud has a silver lining. So don't miss today's continuation of the lecture: Chapter IV "conspiracy theory". It will be interesting. :)
Did you even understand what he said???)))
Ушел с героев, пока пряники)
Дубровин Павел
Auto-translated
Alright Pasha, the message finally got through to you!!!
Now tell me, can anyone file a complaint if a rival, having caught the opponent cheating, doesn't have any objections???!!!!:smile12:
Roma, if we follow the current rules of the Arbitration Committee (AK), then any user of the World of Xen (WoX) platform, even if they are not a participant in the disputed game,
can contact the AK with a request to review the game of its participants (registered on WoX).
С истиной где-то рядом...
Лето 2010.
Лето 2010.
Catch
Auto-translated
Roma, if we are guided by the current AC rules, then any user of Vold, even if not a participant in the disputed game,
can contact the AC with a request to review the game of its participants (registered on Vold).
Bayevs registered on HeroesWorld, tremble!!!:smile10: The AC is coming for you! :smile24: