Posts from Rules for Heroes of Might and Magic III online tournaments on HeroesWorld. Auto-translated

My top 5 for the Academy: 1) Alex_R 2) LeBron 3) Pit for LM 4) vbn 5) Dubrovin Pavel

I would also like to write once about the organizational aspects of the issue...

I will try to outline my vision of the working conditions for the review group...

A. The review group's communication with the rest of the forum members should be minimal, i.e., through an intermediary – it should not depend on the authority of the forum member or other similar factors.
1. The review group should have an odd number of members, and no one should abstain from voting.
2. No forum member should know how each member of the review group voted individually; only the collective decision should be known.
3. The review group, if possible, should not know whose case they are reviewing; only the facts, save files, and chat logs should be provided.
4. If any member of the review group has questions for any of the forum members involved in the dispute, all communication should be anonymous and through the intermediary.

B. The resolution of disputed issues should not be prolonged.
1. The intermediary between the review group and the forum members should forward their claims of unfair play within a specified number of days.
2. The intermediary should have several deputies. There should be several people who can replace members of the review group who, for some reason, cannot participate in the forum during the current period. This will prevent the review group from being affected by the fact that its members may have other matters to attend to and cannot be on the forum for some time.
3. The review group should consider these claims within a specified number of days from the date of the last fact or replacement, as mentioned in the previous point.
4. If the review group cannot reach a decision within this period, it will be dissolved, and a new review group will be elected.

I may think of something else later...

Oh, guys, so many great suggestions! I'll try to sort them out by the evening. For now, just this: vbn (9:49): I confirm. Regarding 7 people in the AC – I support it, I even think it's preferable. And I received a message from Mizrael, but I didn't understand: Mizrael (8:50): [unintelligible characters] which translates to: Mizrael (08:46:02 20/05/2009) Hello, I agree, of course – it's a necessary and useful thing. Pasha usually appears in the evening.

He also received a message from Mizrael, but didn't understand it:
Mizrael ‎(8:50):
@825B

The poor guy was abducted by aliens:(

Candidates for the Appeals Commission:
1. Alex_R
2. Mizrael
3. LeBron
4. Pit for LM
5. scorp
6. vbn
7. Дубровин Павел

We've reached the voting stage. And here are the rules (I do love them :D ):
1. Anyone can vote. However, only votes from registered HeroesWorld users who are also HOMM3 online players will be counted. That is, the voter must have played at least one game with a report posted on HeroesWorld. I am neither able nor willing to divide votes into "us" and "them" based on resource affiliation.
2. - You can vote for the entire list at once. This would mean you want to see the Appeals Commission with this specific number and composition of members.
- You can vote FOR 1 to 6 candidates and indicate the total number of people you would like to see on the Commission. For example, I vote for Mr. N, I don't know the others and I don't care, but there should be 4 people in total. Vote only for those you trust and whose competence you do not doubt.
- You can also vote AGAINST any or all candidates. This will also be taken into account.
3. You can vote OPENLY in this thread, SECRETLY* via a Private Message on the forum to me (Pit for LM) or to Nagan-4, as well as to me via ICQ (471401475). When voting via ICQ — you can send an offline message; be sure to correctly state your HeroesWorld nickname and you must receive confirmation from me (I sometimes receive messages from aliens).
4. Comrades listed in the slate do not vote for themselves (they have already voted by agreeing to be included in this list).
5. The voting will tentatively last until 24:00 on May 24, 2009 (for some reason I think it will end sooner). I will inform you daily about its progress and results. I kindly ask you to suspend discussion of other topics if possible until the voting ends, to make things easier for me.
* The secrecy of the vote will be preserved within the following limits: I will format the final results as an EXCEL table and pass them to the moderators ewgeniy, vbn, Ta Kotoraya..., and to Nagan-4.

My choice: 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7. And for 7 people.

Yes, if it's possible to choose 7 people, then my choice is:

Ta Kotoraya;

Pit for LM;

Scorp;

Mizrael;

Vbn;

Alex R;

LeBron.

Also voting for 7, but in this format:
Ta Kotoraya;

Pit for LM;

Scorp;

Mizrael;

Vbn;

Alex R;

Dubrovin Pavel..

if there are five:
Pit for LM
vbn
Alex_R
Ta Kotoraya...
scorp
and if there are seven, then +
Mizrael
Dubrovin Pavel

I repeat once again the list of candidates for the Appeals Committee, which will deal with controversial issues and negative phenomena on our forum: 1. Alex_R 2. Mizrael 3. LeBron 4. Pit for LM 5. scorp 6. vbn 7. Dubrovin Pavel To Dubrovin Pavel and SEM_56. Friends, have some pity on the girl! It's not right for her to delve into our dirty laundry! Doesn't she already spend enough time removing profanity on the forum? And now you want to give her access to chat logs to look at? She already has moderation duties, clan wars, and team tournaments... She even wrote that

But overall, I like the idea of subcommittees more.

That's why she's not on the list.

I personally prefer AA, especially in online play with pre-flop action, but AK is also good:p
Here's the list:
Pit
Dubrovin
VBN
Mizrael
And let's get Scorpa away from poker and have him play AK here :)

Having explained the situation, I will heed your wisdom and suggest Dirty_Player...
He has been annoying me since the first days on the forum (in a good way), let it continue...

Also, I want to make an amendment!
Tournaments should not all take place at once, followed by a six-month lull, but rather according to their importance or in sequence (so that there is enough time for participation)...

1. Dirty player
2. Mizrael
3. vbn
4. Dubrovin Pavel.
5. Alex R
6. Oelm
7. invisible

Dirty Player, vbn, Alex_R, Pit for LM, Mizrael, Scorp, Dubrovin Pavel, LeBron

IMHO: VBN, Nagan, Pit, Dreamcatcher, Dubrovin, Ewgeniy, Loi.

Currently, 13 people have voted: bRitvo4kA, Pit for LM, He3Hauka, Dirty_Player, Dubrovin Pavel, Sem 56, SpiriTT, , Hermit, ewgeniy, LeBron, OUTLAW, Dekontaminator. Thank you!
Preliminary results (the first number is FOR, the second is AGAINST):
1. Alex_R - 8-1
2. Mizrael - 10-0
3. LeBron - 8-0
4. Pit for LM - 11-0
5. scorp - 10-0
6. vbn - 13-0
7. Dubrovin Pavel - 8-2

Thank you for the votes cast for our respected forum members who are not on the list. I am also recording this information. I would also have given all my votes to Nagan-4 if he hadn't withdrawn himself. But when compiling the list, I had to take into account not only our wishes, but also the opinions and capabilities of those who were nominated. ewgeniy also withdrew, which is not surprising given his workload on the forum. Loi and invisible, I hope, will return to us, but so far they have not expressed such a desire.
Therefore, I ask you to look at the list first and choose from it. These people have agreed to do a lot of complex work. Show who you trust among them.