Posts from A unified hero ranking for the entire Russian-speaking internet.

I've decided to implement this project on my hosting :) If the community finds this idea useful and promising, I ask you to review the first version of this project: http://dreamcatcher.metroland.ru/index1.php Currently, it supports user registration and all the necessary functions for managing reports and navigating the list with various parameters. You can register fictitious reports, confirmations, and refutations there for testing the technical aspects. Regarding the rating, I anticipate a problem: which formula to use. However, there isn't a significant problem either, because it's possible to calculate simultaneously using different formulas. I ask players who are knowledgeable in this area to decide and recommend one or more formulas to me.

The idea is excellent! HOWEVER, it would be very desirable to combine all resources into one, as this would increase the objectivity of the rating.

The idea itself is good. Therefore, I believe it should be supported. If enough people join and the project gains momentum, the danger lies in the potential for duplicates or clones. Where someone writes a report and registers a clone that seemingly confirms it...

And then there's the "scoring system." How will it be calculated, using the Stinky formula or the Elo system?

The rating is intended to be general for all resources. When submitting a report, there is an option to link the game to a specific website, but this is only for statistical purposes, as well as for the possibility of calculating a custom rating for a set of games on a particular website, and who knows what else it might be useful for. The problem of clones is the same as the problem of cheating in games.

To StickyFingaz
I don't think it's necessary to combine all resources into one, but tracking statistics for all resources on a single website could be a good idea...

Final link:
http://dreamcatcher.metroland.ru
The main functionality has been implemented. You can test it on real games.
The rating formula was taken from TOH:
http://toheroes.com/new.htm
Rn = Ro + 30 + 0.05 * (D) for the winner, and Rn = Ro - (20 + 0.05 * (D)) for the loser,
where Rn is the new rating (after the game), Ro is the old rating (before the game), and (D) is the difference between the players' ratings.
For example: if a player with a rating of 1000 (starting) defeats a player with 1100, the winner rises to 1035, and the loser drops to 1075. If, however, a player with a rating of 1100 defeats a player with 1000, the winner becomes 1125, and the loser drops to 985.

Registered. For some reason, I was given 1500 points right away instead of 1000. They must respect me :) What should be added: 1) The ability to specify "random" instead of a starting hero. Also, the ability to specify that the game started, say, not with a Castle, but with a random Castle. There are enough people who like to play full-random, and their interests should be taken into account. 2) For games on fixed maps, the ability to specify the map name. And the color options should not only be red-blue, but the entire spectrum. 3) For non-standard templates, specify the template name. 4) Make the "add new report" button larger and higher up. For example, in the upper left corner. It's a small thing, but it would be nice. 5) Sort the castles in the list according to their standard order. 6) The choice of starting hero should not be from the full list, but from the list of heroes of the selected castle. The final hero should, by default, match the starting hero (and change automatically when switching). You can set typical starting heroes by default. This is all to reduce the number of clicks. 7) *Attention! An error will occur when submitting the report if you make a mistake with the password or have unconfirmed games. To avoid losing the carefully typed text, save it in advance!* Sounds ominous. Maybe just make some kind of reminder, a pop-up window. Or just not allow posting the report until the rest has been confirmed/denied. The same applies to the password - automatically fill in the winner field without the ability to edit it. 8) "Day of Victory" sounds pompous :). You could use something like "game duration". 9) The ability to view the entire ranking, not just the top 10

Item 0 - fixed, item 9 - already working. I will definitely finish the rest over time.
An unpleasant incident occurred: while working, I accidentally deleted the user table. Please forgive me and register again.