UNIFIED RULES FOR CLAN WARS Auto-translated

Since this section is simply cluttered with various posts, I propose the following Unified Rules for clan-versus-clan war declarations:

Two options:

Option 1. Each existing clan creates a thread in which it indicates that it is ready to accept challenges from other clans (e.g., as the Order of the Phoenix did). If desired, players and HoMM versions can be specified. Accordingly:

A clan declaring war leaves a post in the thread of the clan to which war is declared, indicating:
1. Its name.
2. The name of the clan to which war is declared.
3. The reason for declaring war (if necessary).
4. The HoMM version that will be the battlefield.
5. The players representing the clan in tournaments.
6. Other conditions (type of tournament, map, number of players, restrictions, etc.).

The clan to which war is declared leaves a post in its own thread with the following content:
1. Agreement or disagreement with the challenge (accepts or declines the challenge).
2. In case of agreement: players representing the clan in tournaments; other conditions not specified by the clan declaring war.
3. In case of disagreement, the reason is indicated. A clan may decline the challenge if there are no players available for the HoMM version specified by the clan declaring war.

Since military and other alliances are being formed, an allied clan can participate in tournaments in two ways:
1. Independently declare war on the clan to which war has been declared. In this case, the latter will be fighting on two fronts, and the ally (of one or another clan) must leave a corresponding post in the thread of the clan to which war is declared.
2. Participate in the battle on the map as a third party (ally). In this case, it indicates the players representing the clan in tournaments, in the same thread.

Option 2. A separate thread (one, without division by clans) is created, in which the same information is posted as indicated above.

The options are not final and are subject to discussion.
As I understand it, so far it turns out that one person issues a challenge, and the rest do nothing (where are the clan wars in this case?). In addition, there are no real wars because there are no clear rules.

I'm in favor of option one, and the sooner the better, because some people are already eager to announce it.

What is the reason for the war? Maybe I don't know enough about inter-clan life, but for example, there were no reasons for wars: no insults, etc... Maybe it would be better to write not "reason for war," but "competitions" or something similar?
P.S.: Why wars? Competitions are more humane.

What is the reason for the war? Maybe I don't know much about inter-clan life, but for example, there were no reasons for wars: no insults, etc... Maybe it would be better to write not "reason for war," but "competitions" and so on?
P.S.: Why wars? Competitions are more humane.

It seems to me that wars sound arrogant, but competitions?

It might sound arrogant, but the conditions should be different for her...
and you can't just declare war like it's a competition...

Let me put it this way: the rules for competitions and wars will be determined by the clans themselves (I mean the rules regarding the number of players, the version, etc.), and the concept of whether it's a war or a competition will also be determined by the competing (warring) clans. These rules (mentioned above) are needed so that wars (competitions) actually begin, to organize this section, so that I can go to a clan's topic in this section, write a post, wait for a response, and the clan members fight!!! Whether it's called a war or a competition doesn't matter to me as a leader... However, competitions still imply some rivalry in achieving a goal (or rather, a reward, points, etc.), and I will think about this, but it is still a slightly different question.

But why war? Draco, why start a war?

Why wage war? Draco, what's the point of starting a war?

War (Competition) is necessary to prove the superiority of one Clan over another.

War (Competitive) is needed to prove the superiority of one clan over another.

There are clan rankings to resolve this issue; everything is clear there.

It might sound arrogant, but it should also have different conditions...
You can't just declare war like you declare a Competitive event...

And no one will declare war just like that (at least I hope not); there are Clan Wars for Competitive events. War is War.

But why war? Drako, why stir up war?

Well... let's just say that Drako isn't the one stirring it up; he's just showing those who will stir it up how to do it properly)).

What's the reason for war? Maybe I don't know enough about inter-clan life, but there haven't been any reasons for wars, such as insults, etc...

Yes... that means you don't know enough)). And even when it comes to insults, people here don't issue challenges; they just make comments and lower Battle Ratings)). The point is that people can't live peacefully, no matter what. Different people with different worldviews discuss their favorite game on the forum, so why not challenge the clan that has offended you?
An ideal society does not exist, and conflicts will always exist.

I'm for one option, and I hope it happens soon, because some people already want to declare war.

You talk about it as if it's nothing, just declaring war. But there will be consequences, and the magnitude of these consequences will depend on the nature of the clan you're going to declare war on. This isn't a Clan War, where you play peacefully and then go your separate ways...
(Sorry, but I might have too harsh a concept of war, but that's how it is.)

I read everything here, and I still don't understand what the possible reasons for declaring war could be.

I read everything here, and I still don't understand what reasons there could be for declaring war?

There are many different reasons – from dislike of a particular person from a particular clan to intense hatred of the clan (you might say that there is no such thing on the forum, and everyone loves each other, but that's not true; they just keep quiet).
If someone insults someone else, that's also a good reason for war. But I don't think anyone will declare war without a reason. People are like that – they will always find a reason if one is needed.

Let's replace the word "war" with "tournament." As if there aren't enough wars in the world and in Heroes... let's start one here on the forum too. Or do we not have enough arguing already?
None of this will lead to anything good. I'm against war; it's unnecessary.

I completely agree with Dragon Malassa. There should be reasons for declaring "war." And they should probably be described in the first post.

3. Reason for declaring war (if necessary).

I don't understand this:smile07: ...

What’s wrong with war? What does swearing have to do with it? Clans are created to wage wars. Or are you afraid that everyone will come out with machine guns? :P There was a thread called "Phoenix Order challenges to a duel," and they didn't start fighting there. You shouldn't take everything so personally, and there's nothing deadly about inter-clan warfare. War implies competition (Tournament), so all these concerns about swearing seem unfounded to me.

A Clan that declares war leaves a post in the clan's topic about declaring war on this clan, in which it indicates:

Let’s go!!!
:smile13: :smile14:
Draco, unfortunately, your clan's topic is locked, so you can find all useful information here:
/topic/at/146012/

:) a small suggestion

Introduction:
don't you think that all these clan wars are pointless for now...?

if someone wants to play with me, there's no need to challenge my clan; just ask me, and we'll agree on a time and play ;)

at the moment, winning a clan war means your victory will quickly fade and be forgotten :) we need something more substantial.

For example: keeping track of victories and defeats in clan wars in the representative threads, awarding a medal to clan members (or specific participants in the clan war), or generally some kind of "tribute," and an incentive :) (for example, a separate ranking for clan wars) or a point system where points are taken when winning against another clan, and so on.

Suggestion:
so, what are your thoughts on this? should we create an incentive?
or should we just leave everything as it is :) just a challenge, just a game (which could be done without a challenge?)

although I think no one has time for this :)