Skip to content

Posts from “Best map for Heroes of Might and Magic III” (2007).

Contests Closed Topic
4.4 (7 ratings)
User Avatar
Auto-translated
CONTEST: "Best HeroesWorld map of 2007
for Heroes of Might and Magic 3"

КОНКУРС Лучшая карта для героев меча и магии 3 за 2007г на HeroesWorld[/CENTER]

This thread will be used to evaluate all maps created by esteemed mapmakers wishing to take part in the annual contest for the best map!


To participate in the contest, you must familiarize yourself with the rules below:

1. The map must be at least 72x72 (preferably with a Dungeon).
2.
The map can be made in any editor (except WOG)!!!
3.
The map must be created by you personally.
4.
The map must contain heroes with the nicknames of forum members.
5. Send the completed map to the email address VDV_forever@BK.RU, or post it in this thread


The participant must remember:


1. If a player claims a map that is not their own, they will be automatically excluded from the contest and punished.
2. Maps made in a map generator are not accepted!!!

Contest dates:


Maps will be accepted until November 20, 2007; the winner will be determined on November 30, 2007!
After receiving your map, you will see in the application table that:

the map has been received and is under review - indicated by a bold Nickname.
the map has been accepted - indicated by an italicized bold Nickname.


Prizes:

1. There will be only one winner.
2. A reward in the form of a Virtual prize in the profile and under the avatar.
3. A certificate of honor from www.heroesworld.ru (Sent by mail).



Map Evaluation.

Maps will be evaluated based on the following categories:


1. Map size, presence of a Dungeon. 72X72 - 10 points, 108x108 - 15 points, 144x144 - 20 points, Dungeon - 10 points.
2. Map density (i.e., absence of "empty space"). Max points - 20.
3. Number and, most importantly, quality of mini-quests. Max points - 10.
4. Beauty of the landscape and the world in general. Max points - 10.
5. Presence of balance (the map should be designed for high-level players). Max points - 10.
6. Thoughtfulness and strength of neutral monsters. Max points - 10.
7. Thoughtfulness and strength of the computer opponent. Max points - 10.


Judges:

VDV_forever, Kolb@zzer, Sage


1. After testing the map, each judge evaluates it on each of the 7 points and assigns points from a minimum of 1 point to the maximum (specified within each point).
2. Each judge is required to give an objective evaluation (summary) for every map. In this evaluation, judges must specify all pros and cons of the map and provide a conclusion.
3. The judge has the right:

- If there are errors that make the map impassable, deduct up to 20 points per error;
- If there are errors but the map is passable despite them, deduct up to 5 points per error;
- Deduct points for aspects not included in the above points if this is mentioned in the summary;
- Return the map to the tournament participant to fix errors and shortcomings.

An offline tournament called "Best of the Best - 2" will be held on our website for the "Best Homm3 Map", i.e., the map that takes first place in the contest!


PARTICIPANT LIST
NUMBERPARTICIPANT NICK MapDate ModifiedRating
1AlexeyPank
2Алисия
3Kimmanuel Oblodra
4<))Dimitrius((>
5Dmitry_A_S
6SandroXXL14.09.07 (1)
7Ley
8Александр Г.К.26.09.07 (0)
9Ganymed31.08.07 (0)
10Entony
11Maximula31.08.07 (0)
12Vanechka14.09.07 (1)
13Fenix31.08.07 (0)
14Denminator17.10.07 (1)
15Joyce31.08.07 (0)
16lankwe17.10.07 (2)
17PrutkoFF14.09.07 (0)
18Vasko
19Windows Vienna
20Knight-voland23.10.07 (0)
21Max7146.11.07 (0)
22Драко20.11.07 (0)
23RAPER20.11.07 (0)
24Freeman11.11.07 (0)

For those whose map was made in WOG, it is suggested to convert it to SOD using a special program /attachments/5148/

Thread where you can ask questions about this program:

/topic/at/107043/


Good luck.

Sincerely, VDV_forever
Единый справочник по Героям Меча и Магии

ТУРНИРЫ ПО ГЕРОЯМ 1!:smile13:
User Avatar
Auto-translated
K0Lb@zzeR, why isn't my map listed?
Sub specie aeternitatis.

Под знаком вечности.

In reply to РУХ-ЧУДИЩЕ-ОГР
User Avatar
Auto-translated
Hello, dear forum members and mapmakers!

Please accept my apologies for my prolonged absence from the forum.

Due to the fact that the workload increases several times towards the end of the year, I had to urgently go on a business trip, and upon my return, I had to focus on solving the tasks at my main job, temporarily leaving the forum. Unfortunately, the trend of a large workload at my main job will continue at least until the end of the year, so my presence on the forum during this period will be rare; please understand.

Of course, I do not relieve myself of my obligations to you regarding the topics and sections that I manage for the benefit of the forum. Therefore, in any case, one of the most interesting, popular, and long-running topics, such as the "Best HOMM3 map of 2007" topic, will be completed and finalized as it should be, with all the consequences, such as awarding prizes and holding the Best of the Best2 tournament!

At the same time, a significant number of maps have been submitted in recent days, so the workload on the judges evaluating the maps has increased significantly. Therefore, the final results may be delayed by a few days. Everything will depend on when I receive the final reports on all the maps from our esteemed judges.

I ask you, Sage and Kolb@zzer, to send all the missing materials for evaluating each map presented in the table, according to the categories indicated in the first post of this topic, as soon as possible. Also, please send a summary for each map.

A HUGE THANK YOU TO ALL OUR MAPMAKERS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS CONTEST! ALL THE MAPS ARE INTERESTING, UNIQUE, AND DIFFERENT FROM EACH OTHER! EACH HAS ITS OWN UNIQUE FEATURE!

Unfortunately, I cannot say the same about the maps that did not pass the selection due to the minimum requirements that were set. There were many such maps:
Durik1 and Durik 2 – maps that not only did not meet the requirements but also contained offensive language.
Fear – the author was unable to convert the map to the COD version.
Испытание - the author was unable to correctly convert the map to the COD version (the map crashes constantly, unfortunately).
Also, maps that were archived in incomprehensible archives, had a strange extension, maps that were taken from other Internet resources, as well as maps whose users are not registered on the site and did not leave an application in the contest topic.
All of them, unfortunately (although I tried to explain to the esteemed mapmakers what they needed to do to participate in the contest), were unable to join the competition for the best map.

HERE ARE THE MAPS THAT SHOULD BE INCLUDED IN THE TABLE AND CONSIDERED BY THE JUDGES:
1. Lord of the Elements, author unknown (Kulichenov Ilya <azzazeloknight??? yarik_dolmatov??? if the author does not announce himself, then it will have to be excluded>
2. Ring, Three Kings, Princess, author Draco.
3. He who has eyes will see, author RAPER

P.S. At the moment, I have evaluated and finalized the results for 13 maps in 17 Word documents.

P.P.S. I also installed a high-speed internet connection, but it's of little use, as there is absolutely no time to figure out why something is being downloaded from an unknown source (Outpost doesn't see it, unfortunately). In a couple of minutes, 12 MB of something unknown is downloaded...
Maybe someone knows what this is, all Windows update services are disabled, programs are not being updated, what is the reason? Moreover, this invisible process starts within 10-12 seconds!

Sincerely, VDV_forever
Единый справочник по Героям Меча и Магии

ТУРНИРЫ ПО ГЕРОЯМ 1!:smile13:
User Avatar
Auto-translated
Hmm... I'm asking in advance, will there be a contest for the best map of 2008? I've finished that development map (not a Trial map), and I'm thinking maybe I should submit it to a new contest instead of just leaving it as is.
Sub specie aeternitatis.

Под знаком вечности.

User Avatar
Auto-translated
RUKH-CHUDISHCHE-OGR, you've stuffed the map with WoG objects again during the refinement process. You should probably reinstall SoD into a separate folder or something. The lava in the center of the map is a WoG object, as is the snow. Or did you make a mistake and upload the wrong file again? In any case, it's too late now. As for the Best Map of 2008, there will definitely be a contest. That's just my feeling.
Просто еще один
User Avatar
Auto-translated
Oh, come on... even if it doesn't work out, I'll wait until 2008... then I'll upload my map (not a challenge map)... I have time now, so I'll keep improving it... The main thing is that in a year, no one will stop playing Heroes of Might and Magic!
Sub specie aeternitatis.

Под знаком вечности.

User Avatar
Auto-translated
2 RUH-CHUDISCHE-OGR:
No one is going to start playing heroes! :). A person's workload can only postpone it... :).
If a similar competition takes place next year, I will definitely hope that there will be more maps and participants. Although, of course, VDVforever might be busy or other difficulties may arise, but I still hope that there will be people who will support VDV's idea... :).

Sincerely.
"Единственное, что можно сказать с уверенностью об удаче - она изменит..."
User Avatar
Auto-translated
Heroes are IMMORTAL!!!! I think that's what the map contest will be called in about 5-7 years))))
Sub specie aeternitatis.

Под знаком вечности.

In reply to Драко
User Avatar
Auto-translated
Good day, dear contest participants! This week (i.e., by December 10th), the final results of the contest will definitely be announced, and the winner will be determined! I have evaluated all the maps, checked them, summarized the results, and made a decision. Dear contest judges, please hurry up with evaluating the maps and send all your work, as well as the results, to my email address. P.S. I hope all contest participants will take part in the offline tournament Best of the Best 2. Sincerely, VDV_forever

Added 23 hours 35 minutes ago
Good day, dear map creators and contest judges! I unfairly failed to include the map Very bad day, by Freeman in the list of maps for evaluation. The reason is that I couldn't unzip it at home (apparently, the archiver was old), but I managed to do it at work. In this regard, and also because the map was sent on November 11th and meets all the rules of the contest, I ask you to also pay attention to it. I ask the judge to also give it an objective evaluation. Sincerely, VDV_forever
Единый справочник по Героям Меча и Магии

ТУРНИРЫ ПО ГЕРОЯМ 1!:smile13:
User Avatar
Auto-translated
I want to participate, the map is in progress!
I hope it's still possible.
User Avatar
Auto-translated
I want to participate, the map is in progress!
I hope it's still possible.
Unfortunately, no... the contest ended on November 20th – please read the terms and conditions more carefully.
играю на уровне AI !!:smile32: ;)
In reply to RAPER
User Avatar
Auto-translated
Good day, dear contest participants!

Please allow me to thank all of you for successfully completing the contest for the best map!

In fact, all the maps you submitted contained that special something that a map created by a robot-computer cannot have, and thank you for that! Thank you for your hard work, your dedication, and your achievements!

I thank all the participants who took part in the contest once again, and I wish you health, success in your studies, work, and personal life, and of course, in Mapmaking for such a wonderful game as Heroes 3! I hope that the new year 2008 will bring us interesting, new, and high-quality maps that will be duly appreciated by the players of our portal. I would like to believe that in 2008 we will see both old and experienced Mapmakers from our forum, as well as new participants who have joined this large community of Mapmakers, ready to compete in creating new and new masterpieces!:smile13:

Congratulations to Mapmaker Knight-voland on his victory! Please contact me via PM and provide your home address, where the certificate of honor for the best Mapmaker of 2007 will be sent!

P.S. Any participant can familiarize themselves with the detailed summary by downloading this file to their computer.



P.S.S. Kyle, it's your turn…;

P.S. Due to the large amount of work at my main job, there will be no surprises from VDV_forever on the Best of the Best map, but they will be from the respected Kyle!;

Sincerely, VDV_forever
Attachments 1
1 file attached • Total size: 28.5 KB
Единый справочник по Героям Меча и Магии

ТУРНИРЫ ПО ГЕРОЯМ 1!:smile13:
User Avatar
Auto-translated
Congratulations, Knight-Voland!!! The map is really very good.
User Avatar
Auto-translated
Well, congratulations to the winner....=) and I'm currently in a modest
3rd place =) it's a pity that I didn't have enough time to fully refine the map's balance and the beauty of the world (although I spent more time on it than anything else)... =) well, what can you do...
Thanks, VDV, for the great contest... next year (I hope) I'll participate and fight for the victory ;) =
играю на уровне AI !!:smile32: ;)

Statistics

Welcome our newest member: Emil