Hall of Shame: discussion. Auto-translated

The main thing is to prevent the Hall of Fame from turning into a tool for settling scores. We need to ensure that someone can't submit a pre-prepared, cheating save file under another player's name to get revenge. In such a situation, we can, of course, figure out who is ultimately to blame, but it will take a lot of time and effort. Therefore, to avoid this, I suggest that the issue of cheating be resolved by the tournament organizer and several random players on the portal who are not participating in the tournament. (Similar to a judge and jury). But this is just my opinion.

Hmm... Zhenya, one question. Does the "violation of the manifesto" ban apply only to members of the Guild or not? Because if it does, then the violator can say that they are not a member of any Guild, that they haven't violated the forum rules, and that they are simply being insulted.

Hmm... Zhenya, one question. Does the "violation of the manifesto" ban apply only to members of the Guilds and Alliances (GI) or not? Because if so, the violator can say that they are not a member of any GI, have not violated the forum rules, and are simply being insulted.

How the ban board works:
If a user violates the manifesto (they must be a member of a GI), write a message in this thread - the user receives a warning; if the user repeatedly violates the manifesto, they will be added here.

Any questions?:p
PS Regarding Gramm's post, I'll say this:
Without serious evidence and witnesses, without talking to the violator, I'm not going to do anything, and in general, I hope the ban board won't be needed:smile31:

Zhen, it was definitely time to implement this idea. But there's just one BUT. Well, you know... just change it so it's not "her," because it just feels a bit off: D

Repeatedly insulting a user(s)

I think there should be a "Hall of Fame"! If there's a "wall of shame," then you can argue that we all have our flaws, but some people are just a little bit worse. If there's a "Hall of Fame," then the argument is that we're all good, but some people are just a little bit better than others.

One doesn't preclude the other. It's perfectly possible to combine them. However, the "hall of fame" would also need some kind of division (e.g., into best players, people who have done a lot for the portal, etc.).

Well, then, there’s also the “Best Newcomer on the Portal” award and so on, “Best Clan,” “Best Battle,” and so on.

Yeah, and now tell me, how do your suggestions relate to the Heroes International? The best clan and the best battle have nothing to do with mutual respect among participants. And what even is the "best newcomer"?!

Is there a forum section that isn't related to Heroes of Might and Magic, but is dedicated to the best clan, hero, etc.?
I don't think I've seen one.
If not, it would be worth creating one. The community should know its heroes :) So why not have Heroes of Might and Magic take care of it? After all, the concept of a "board" already brings these things together :)

:)) putting the board in the grave and being on the same page also brings people together :))

let's continue the topic and make nominations with voting: best player of the month, best clan of the month, and even best battle of the month in the top 5. :)) and best newcomer is also a good topic.

let's look at the newcomers over the last three months and see who has actively joined and who hasn't :) sorry for the off-topic if anything :)

Added 7 minutes later
there are many nominations we can come up with :) for example, a newcomer who doesn't understand where they've ended up :) Clan-Camper :) that's also relevant, the Most Evil clan )) we also have contenders :)

damn, I'm already completely off-topic, but we need to do a battle by factions or at least light versus dark (on any of the versions) like the All-Star East versus West, that would be a MEGA topic :))

(of course, after the other two mega tournaments, Friendship of Nations and against by, are held)

Why are all these questions being discussed in this thread? As I understand it, this should only be a Hall of Fame, and everything else is unnecessary. Or am I wrong?

well, if we're talking about nominations... I just don't want to create a separate thread specifically for that. But if it's about the tournament, I'll go create a new thread now.

Guys, stop arguing about the best clan of the month, okay?
Seriously, when I imagine it... We have 2 inter-clan tournaments, and neither of them is working :( and in general, it's all off-topic - this thread contains a forum, and here you need to report about rule breakers/violations.

Question: Why is the "Hall of Fame" section placed second? It slightly spoils the overall impression.

Guys, maybe we should stop discussing this topic! It seems like everything has been resolved!
It's in the past... Let's not dwell on it. We just need to keep in mind that if something like this happens again, we should all just leave the chat and not respond to provocations! And the moderators (I mean all of them, including those whose nicknames aren't green, but who can delete posts in the chat – there were not only me, Ghost, and Ada that day, but also Sverkha, who can also delete posts in the chat, and possibly someone else; I was only there for 10 minutes and didn't see who else was there) should delete this nonsense and, at the same time, call the coordinators (although any forum user can do this, since the ICQ number of any coordinator is in their profile).
In my opinion, these are the actions that simply need to be taken in this situation. IMHO.
Instead of staying silent and then blaming others, saying that they succumbed to the provocation! Anyone could have called the hacker, but they did it two hours later! Alex couldn't restrain himself, but we shouldn't shame him for it! He's just a person! In general, I have nothing more to say! This topic has already been put to rest! Let's stop picking at it!

Sorry if I was too harsh! I don't want to offend anyone! In fact, everyone is good, to be honest! Including myself; I'm not absolving myself of blame!

With respect to everyone! Sorry if I said anything wrong!