I was at "Whisky Live" on Saturday. I'm sharing my notes; I didn't write them all evening just for myself. Everything is extremely unprofessional, everything is very subjective – but it’s honest. Here’s how it went:
First, I tried
Soldshu 12 years – a blend made by one of our compatriots from Scottish aged spirits.
Color: bright gold, reflects light well.
Nose: cream, spices, berries (raspberry/blackberry).
Taste: repeats the nose, very smooth and drinkable, weak flavor intensity, medium-bodied.
Finish: weak, short, fruits (pear, apple), berries.
Rating:
85/100. Smooth, tasty, interesting, unusual, but too weak. But it was perfect to start the festival.
Before moving on to single malts, I had another blend –
McGuire 18 years, named after Frank McGuire, a musician and guest at that festival.
Color: bright, reddish-caramel.
Nose: not alcoholic at all, very soft, sweetness, floral aroma, cream.
Taste: ??? Nothing clear, monotonous.
Finish: weak, slightly malty, sweetness, cinnamon(?).
Rating:
78/100. Soft, good nose – but no other merits. I wonder what McGuire himself said about it?
Let's continue, in order of tasting.
Highland Park Russia Cask. Cask strength – 63.8

Color: black tea, matte.
Nose: not alcoholic, cream, dried fruits, oak, maybe caramel, long inhale – bourbon, herbs (???).
Taste: powerful, rich, but not harsh at all. Wood and dried fruit. Full-bodied, "warm".
Finish: short, but powerful. Sharpness, oak.
Rating:
88/100. Everything seems fine – drinkable and intense, but a little too straightforward, completely without sophistication. This whisky is like a heroic knight. Strong in spirit, strong in body, kind in nature – but as simple as a lamppost. In reality, I wouldn’t want to drink it often, but I would like to have such a drink on hand. Unfortunately, there are only 570 bottles, and by the time I save up for it, it will be gone. And you can’t find it now anyway.
Glen Scotia Double Cask

Color: clear orange.
Nose: smoky notes, acidity, dried fruits.
Taste: powerful, nuts, slight smoke, prunes.
Finish: sharp, long, peat, smokiness, fortified wine.
Rating:
81/100. Powerful, rich taste, but a bit harsh. Perhaps not bad, but probably not my style. This was the most basic release from this producer, and it gave me certain hopes, which… well, you'll see.
Glen Scotia Victoriana

Color: bright orange.
Nose: very weak, cream, fruit, slightly bourbon-like, vanilla.
Taste: soft, slightly tart, similar to a very weak bourbon.
Finish: long, "animal" tones, bourbon notes.
Rating:
74/100. Seemed very weak and uninteresting. I decided not to try the last one left at the festival from “Glen Scotia”, although now I kind of regret that.
Highland Park 12 y.o. Viking Honour

Color: light reddish, cheerful.
Nose: vanilla, tea, ???, slightly alcoholic, but pleasant.
Taste: smooth, rich, sweetish, tea, citrus, slight smoke, ???.
Finish: medium in length and intensity, slightly "animal", nothing special.
Rating:
86/100. I didn't describe it quite correctly, but I really liked it – tasty, drinkable, and vibrant. It would probably be an excellent everyday whisky. Considering the reasonable (and if you find it at "Lenta," then record-breakingly cheap) price, it is definitely recommended. I myself would buy it; it also looks very festive, and this Scandinavian design appeals to me personally, but in the end, I bought something else, which I will tell you about later.
Nikka Whisky Pure Malt

Nose: alcoholic, citrus, fresh apples, bourbon spice. Overall, the aroma seemed harsh; my cheekbones even tightened.
Taste: slightly harsh, leather, pepper, fruit (weak).
Finish: caramel, weak "animal" tones.
Overall:
78/100. This was my first experience with Japanese whisky: firstly, I have always been skeptical of any whisky other than Scottish (bourbon doesn’t count), and although I understood that the Japanese were likely trying to do a good job (unlike some others), I didn’t truly believe in them. Secondly, all the Japanese whisky available in our city is somehow very expensive. Before tasting that sample, I certainly dismissed my skepticism, but it didn't save the rating. The whisky is a bit harsh and generally uninteresting. You can drink it, of course, but nothing more. Now, Japanese whiskies are only for free tastings; I don't want to pay for something like this yet.
Highland Park 18 y. o.

Color: dark amber, "shimmers".
Nose: not alcoholic, autumn forest, slight vanilla, sherry cask, ???.
Taste: very smooth, excellent balance, herbs, nuts, ???.
Finish: weak, short, wood, ???.
Rating:
88/100. A wonderful whisky, drinkable and balanced, very rich, but I guess I lacked the education to understand it :(. Very subtle aroma and taste; I couldn't recognize even half of it, but its potential is enormous. Sometime later…
Bunnahabhain Stiuireadair

Color: light yellow, straw-colored, with a greenish tint in bright light.
Nose: not alcoholic, dominant saltiness, seaweed, prunes (weak), sherry cask (long nose).
Taste: very smooth, marine, salt, seaweed, slightly spicy, maybe a little tart. The balance is shifted towards salt, but not as strongly as in the smell. Overall, everything is very pleasant.
Finish: pronounced, but not long, again salt, ropes (O_o), a bit malty.
Rating:
90/100. Subjectively inflated, but I really liked it; I would even call this sample "the discovery of the evening." Towards the end, I even had a couple more drams. "Stiureadair" means "helmsman" in Gaelic, and as they told me, this whisky was supposed to evoke associations with a stormy sea and salty breezes. And it succeeded! Close your eyes, take a light breath, then a small sip – and everything will become clear. A unique whisky with a special character, also a candidate for purchase, but it's difficult to get, and still quite expensive. And another problem – it might get boring if you drink too much or too often. A whisky with soul, a whisky for the soul.
Before I have an overdose of memories about that glorious day, die from suddenly overwhelming emotions, and drool while remembering that taste-aroma experience, I’ll stop on this optimistic note. There will be more soon.