Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

First, you need to carefully analyze the save file to understand two things: 1) Is there a clear victory for one of the sides, regardless of the other side's actions (within reasonable limits)? If so, there's no need to complicate things; you can simply award the victory. 2) Is there potential for what Derbent is suspected of? In other words, does the optimal move differ when knowing about the cloak/amulet and when not knowing? If it doesn't differ, then again, there's no need to complicate things; you can suggest continuing from the last save. And only if the previous two points are not sufficient to resolve the conflict can you start thinking about other solutions.