Skip to content

Mafia 103. Ice and Ash

User Avatar
#684
Auto-translated
Sky
Execute MasteR - 4 votes (RiMpel2, Neira Drake, Heroist, KindShaman)
Execute RiMpel2 - 3 votes (Fragment, Yuuhei, MasteR)
Execute KindShaman - 1 vote (Uranium235)
No Vote - 1 vote (WishmasteR)

6 votes are needed for an execution.

No one was executed. The day is closed.
There is a so-called "Elephant Rule." It states that if an innocent is executed, there must be a mafia member among those who voted for the execution. It works almost always; cases where it doesn't work include when the mafia didn't vote at all or in some chaotic multi-clans situations.
However, it seems that those who are being targeted are those who are undesirable to RiMpel, judging by this voting pattern.
Also, there's a non-obvious RiMpel-Fragment pair. I think it's quite obvious, so there must be one innocent among them.
And Fragment is exhibiting typical behavior of a town checker, I must admit.
Let's look further. In this game, who has been targeted besides Ment (and even that was based on overly obvious evidence)? Me, Shaman, and RiMpel. The results of the checkers shouldn't be so bad that not even one mafia member is brought up for a vote. I know it's not me.
Apparently, I'm ready to support RiMpel - if the checkers made bad checks or their results were constantly altered by madness, we won't win this game anyway. So, we need to assume that at least some of the checks were accurate and led to at least some negative votes for execution.
Execute RiMpel

Added 2 minutes ago
Heroist
But in the message I quoted, it clearly stated five, I don't know. Or did only the "chosen ones" possess this secret information?

Initially, I was considering one, but even if there are two, there is still someone else for whom it makes no sense to create a balance in votes between two innocents; it's not that kind of situation, and they don't lose anything if they add a vote to you.
You're thinking correctly.
I also think that at least one mafia member definitely added a vote to me. And it's much more likely to be you than Fragment.

Added 43 seconds ago
Heroist, and tell me, do you agree with my version of the living innocents in the game:
Fritjof, the cook, and 2 checkers?

Added 4 minutes ago
Heroist
But in the message I quoted, it clearly stated five, I don't know.
Sky, is the minimum number of votes required for an execution calculated based on the total number of players in the game, or only based on the number of players who actually have votes, i.e., excluding those who are silenced?
In other words, the same question: "how many votes were needed for an execution yesterday, 4 or 5"?