Mafia 103. Ice and Ash

No?

You're stating the obvious.

I'm curious why you chose these candidates from the entire possible pool... I mean, the logic seems to be: "I see that he writes little, even though he seems to be a strong player," but in fact, Shaman, as far as I can tell, wrote normally... However, you could say that he wrote a little less than usual, and he also mentioned a table but didn't post it, right?) In this regard, yes, it's not like him. Toksa, it seemed to me, wasn't very involved in the discussion. Fragment? Well, he's not particularly constructive or talkative in general.

This is elementary; even a minimal reading will tell you that I suspect them of being Mafia, along with you, and there was also Revan, but you said something about him, and I'd better ask Neyra about him.
But if you're not Mafia, the picture should be different. And in that case, a compromise would be someone who could be Mafia and be on the Mafia team with Ment, and also be a peaceful player on the peaceful team with Ment.
And for some reason, you overlooked Master. I asked about him, not Toksa.
And your versions are terribly vague. It doesn't explicitly say: this one is more likely to be Mafia, this one is less likely to be Mafia.