aka.Ward3n
Auto-translated
A brief comment on each point:
1) In my opinion, this is a strange rule. I think the captain should be a fixed figure. I can understand shuffling players in positions 2, 3, and 4, but I don't think there's any point in changing the captain. And the rule of dividing based on rating, in my opinion, only makes sense for reserve players. I just think that a player like Diabler or Maradjan would easily be taken as the second pick.
And I don't quite understand if there's a possibility to change player positions for each game. I have a feeling that this will create a lot of confusion. The only thing that was bad about the rules of the previous tournament was the inability to make substitutions. I encountered a situation in my team where the captain played in 4 out of 8 games, while a player from the second tier played in only 1 out of 8. This is what needs to be addressed. Also, the final, due to UrukHai's inactivity, turned into a 4v3 game.
2. This is up to you; it won't affect the tournament process.
3. Dima, the only question here is, will you be up for handling all of this? Just imagine. I understand that each player will provide their own pool of 9 templates, and the most popular ones will be selected. Now, just imagine how much trouble you'll create for yourself. Each player will be sorted into tiers – that's fine. But... after the draft, each player will be seeded into tiers 1-4. Then you take these lists of templates and sort them into tiers 1-4 as well. Then you choose the 9 (7) most popular templates for each tier. Wouldn't this be too much work for you? It's a rather lengthy and painstaking process. In my opinion, there was the least chance of error in the selection of templates. The only thing is, I don't know how relevant it is, but maybe you could introduce a trade for color instead of the second player choosing the color. Although, in my opinion, the choice of templates is very color-dependent. So, this is up to you.
4. Everything is as it was before, everything is fine.
5. The Bo2 playoff system is good. But, will there again be an advantage for the captain's game in case of a 6-6 tie, or not?
And the question is, will wins in the series be counted, or will the points of each selected player be counted in the groups?
1) In my opinion, this is a strange rule. I think the captain should be a fixed figure. I can understand shuffling players in positions 2, 3, and 4, but I don't think there's any point in changing the captain. And the rule of dividing based on rating, in my opinion, only makes sense for reserve players. I just think that a player like Diabler or Maradjan would easily be taken as the second pick.
And I don't quite understand if there's a possibility to change player positions for each game. I have a feeling that this will create a lot of confusion. The only thing that was bad about the rules of the previous tournament was the inability to make substitutions. I encountered a situation in my team where the captain played in 4 out of 8 games, while a player from the second tier played in only 1 out of 8. This is what needs to be addressed. Also, the final, due to UrukHai's inactivity, turned into a 4v3 game.
2. This is up to you; it won't affect the tournament process.
3. Dima, the only question here is, will you be up for handling all of this? Just imagine. I understand that each player will provide their own pool of 9 templates, and the most popular ones will be selected. Now, just imagine how much trouble you'll create for yourself. Each player will be sorted into tiers – that's fine. But... after the draft, each player will be seeded into tiers 1-4. Then you take these lists of templates and sort them into tiers 1-4 as well. Then you choose the 9 (7) most popular templates for each tier. Wouldn't this be too much work for you? It's a rather lengthy and painstaking process. In my opinion, there was the least chance of error in the selection of templates. The only thing is, I don't know how relevant it is, but maybe you could introduce a trade for color instead of the second player choosing the color. Although, in my opinion, the choice of templates is very color-dependent. So, this is up to you.
4. Everything is as it was before, everything is fine.
5. The Bo2 playoff system is good. But, will there again be an advantage for the captain's game in case of a 6-6 tie, or not?
And the question is, will wins in the series be counted, or will the points of each selected player be counted in the groups?
Когда рестартов не осталось, обязательно ждите Гурниссона без балисты:D
Комплимент который сделал мой день:
Катя ЭПИК барышня) вы бы видели как пялились на её сиськи молодёж) я та с девушкой был) но всё равно пялился ) потому что хорошие) (с) Browser
Слабая раздача, которую заиграл исключительно из-за колпака на 111. (с) Сатир
Комплимент который сделал мой день:
Катя ЭПИК барышня) вы бы видели как пялились на её сиськи молодёж) я та с девушкой был) но всё равно пялился ) потому что хорошие) (с) Browser
Слабая раздача, которую заиграл исключительно из-за колпака на 111. (с) Сатир
