- Do you have a gift?
- Yes
- Do you have a non-disclosure agreement (NDA)?
- Yes
- Are you from out of town?
- No
The first question is a lie - Vittorio, Victor, Quirrell
The second question is a lie - Simon, Edward, Kot
The third question is a lie - James, possibly Alice and Juliana
Now we need to figure out if Jaconda is innocent, and whether there was a reason to answer in this way, and not another.
I also don't quite understand what perfect flowers have to do with it.
Added 7 minutes ago
MasteR: Execute Heroist
For now, that's how it is. The clue works well in both directions. It seems a bit simple, but who knows, maybe nothing better could be found for the chrysanthemum.
Added 1 minute ago
In my opinion, MasteR's subsequent vote against Heroist based on the clue is pure confirmation bias.