Skip to content
User Avatar
#2301
Auto-translated
That's the whole point. Let's say we have 2 townspeople, 2 members of one cult, and one member of another cult left. Is the game over, or not? Or, even better, 3 people left: town/cult1/cult2.
The cultists have killing Night Actions; a town archer or a person with Double Talk might still be alive in the town. However, if there are no more killing Night Actions or Double Talks left for anyone, it's clear that the cults have lost, as they definitely won't be able to control the limit if there are no more recruitable members in the town.

Added 1 minute ago
And put a limit on the Mafia block as well; how is that better?
Sure, I'll put a limit on everyone except the town blocker; he already has his own limit due to his passive ability.

Added 2 minutes ago
I still don't understand the Cat. He collects the amulet and wins. So, the others lose – or will they play for their own victory, independent of the Cat? If the Cat is alive but hasn't collected the amulet, and only the Mafia is left, does he still win? The point of playing as the Cat is not to die and not let the Maniac find the amulet, and that's it – is that the victory condition?
I suspect you haven't encountered the concept of a personal victory condition yet. In this case, the Cat wins if he collects the amulet; even if he's killed afterward, he wins due to his personal victory condition. Or, if he survives until the end without being left alone with the Maniac and prevents him from collecting the amulet.

Added 1 minute ago
What's the punishment? Immediate modkill, a warning, the team loses – what exactly? From my point of view, breaking a rule is acceptable if the benefits outweigh the consequences. And will the punishment be different if you reveal not your own role, but someone else's? (hint: it shouldn't be, otherwise, by the fact that there's no punishment, you can guess that someone was lying).
Modkill. But if one faction violates the rules twice in a row, they may automatically lose.

Added 5 minutes ago
Does the Mafia, who is a Seer and gets killed, have time to report the result to his team?
He will report the last result of his check.