Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

I suggest we end the discussion here, as it's starting to resemble the tale of "the white bull." The Arbitration Committee has voted and made its decision; there will always be those who disagree. The Arbitration Committee exists to take responsibility for decisions in controversial and sometimes borderline situations. If the current Arbitration Committee's work doesn't satisfy the majority of the forum, you can choose more worthy candidates in the next election. For now, I suggest everyone calm down. The topic is closed for a while; take a breath.