Skip to content

Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

User Avatar
#1375
Auto-translated
Dirty_Player
2Wicc: remember the Tournaments you judged on WТ. There were much more serious bugs caused by software issues. Remember CIS in Odessa, where Mee lost 50k gold (or so) during someone else's turn. You didn’t say then that it was the player's problem who played on WT. In Minsk, Cobra constantly had timer problems; every turn required loading a save. And I don't even mention gray Castles. For some reason, no one thought to consider that this was the player's problem and their version of the game.
I repeat:
Wicc
since there is nothing in the rules about how to act in such situations, the case in question should be considered as falling into a gap in the regulations.
That is, I do not believe that the decision of the Arbitration Committee contradicts the rules; either decision would have been acceptable.

Therefore, I am not calling for the Arbitration Committee to reconsider its decision. However:
Wicc
the decision of the Arbitration Committee should be treated as a legal precedent, which players and judges will rely on, which they will refer to in discussions, etc.
And I really don't like this because:
Wicc
I myself occasionally run Tournaments, and I absolutely don't want to deal with claims like "I lagged, please allow me to finish my turn." But the created precedent gives players the moral right to make such requests and argue them by saying that "the Arbitration Committee allowed it in a similar situation."
Therefore:
Wicc
It’s easier now, while the atmosphere is calm, to fix in public consciousness the idea that the decision of the Arbitration Committee is not the only correct one, and therefore it shouldn’t be relied upon when considering similar cases.
That is, I would be quite happy with clarifying this post in the form of "P.S. The decision made is not a precedent for considering other episodes related to player computer lags."

Experience shows that not all players carefully read the justifications for the decisions of the Arbitration Committee, and opinions may arise, such as:
LuckyF
Well, these are somewhat different things: talking about lags and seeing on stream how these lags actually happen and prevent completing a turn.