Mafia 100. Sylvan: Tree of Life.

Honestly, I thought Pepp was an Elf, like a new player who goes around killing everyone.

I'll never believe that a newbie marksman would randomly shoot at everyone. That's stupid. But Locken always does that; it's his play style. You can ask any of the veterans.

It's strange that the second Mafia team isn't planning to weaken its competitors yet.

I'm afraid they're all just trying to sabotage the town. Or maybe they're just incompetent and can't figure out who the other bad guys are.

Added 2 minutes later

I think it wasn't the Lizard in the newspaper, because someone was defending Heroist. Although it could have been the Paladin, but he's not strong enough to be the strongest inhabitant of the forest.

You know, you're right. And the protection from the Paladin is displayed as a fact without reflecting the nickname. Plus, I think that "the ominous, fear-inducing figure" of Nephela is actually Lolodin's action.
So, Menti wasn't the Lizard, but the Healer.