You're all just being negative. Nobody wants to punish anyone; you're relying solely on a miracle from the Elf. But he can also make mistakes.
The day will end in about three hours, and there's practically no activity. We found a clue on Gur, there's a clue on Mentha (by the way, I'm not saying they're 100% reliable), and there are various suspects based on psychological profiles. But nobody wants to do anything. And then there will be complaints about the poor balance, the bad GM, and so on.