Skip to content

Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

User Avatar
#1176
Auto-translated
Roger-ua
I remembered an incident with Falcone. Falcone's game crashed mid-turn, and it seemed like it was due to an internet lag. However, he remembered that he had 22 minutes left on his turn. I suggested that he continue his turn immediately, and I would add the difference between the time remaining on his turn and 22 minutes to my own time. In other words, he would simply continue his turn, and on my turn, I would account for that difference, save the game, and reload my turn to continue. In this case, since I usually had very little time left on my timer, I would theoretically gain some advantage. But I considered this a fair solution because his game crashed during his turn, and I didn't raise any objections (for example, the opponent could have saved the game before a difficult battle and crashed if the battle turned out badly). However, the opponent insisted on continuing his turn without doing anything for 22 minutes. In this case, a third participant would be needed to monitor the opponent until 22 minutes. Zloy Romantik and Dirty were suggested as people who could monitor the process of doing nothing, but since Zloy Romantik and Falcone were from the same city (St. Petersburg), Dirty seemed like a better option to me. This is a huge problem and a problem with opponents. Later in the game, Falcone proved to be a gentleman, and in return, I gave him 8 minutes, and we parted as friends. In any case, I have only positive impressions of Falcone, despite his stubbornness in resolving this technical issue. I also expressed my opinion to Zloy Romantik and Kosta that I would like to have a ready-made solution in this situation, as crashes happen quite often.

Maybe that's why I wasn't included in the tournament.

Well, the solution you proposed is indeed strange, and the requirement for monitoring the time wasting may be logical, but at the very least, it's not customary here, and it would create extra hassle for the judges. I would like to remind you that corrupted saves appeared only in 2013; how did they manage before that for so many years? //By the way, I haven't seen any epic disputes about suspected map hacking lately, like the ones that used to be against Britvotchka and Chemist; maybe passwords are related to that// I'm saying this because if you don't trust anyone, it's easier not to play at all.

But the decision is strange, of course, but no less strange than the exclusion of Rebellius from the "Outlaw 2" tournament, so this is already a trend.
ICQ 423164784