If you don't mind, it's complicated. As I said, the guys from Shio aren't the most proactive, so a bonus to initiative might not be that great for them. It would work better on the Tactical Element. Also, a debuff on initiative should work well for heroes with strong magic. A buff on initiative, on the other hand, works better against such heroes (and generally works stronger if the enemy actually has a hero, although how important this is is a question). In general, there are many nuances here, and it's difficult to assess all of this unambiguously, at least without numerous (very numerous) tests. So I would consider these abilities to be roughly equal (with the same mathematical effects).
NHF 0.90 : NHF - группа в VK
Карты для HeroesV:
Путешествие , Условие крови , Рука судьбы.Часть 1: В поход , Рука судьбы.Часть 2: Отчаянье , Рука судьбы.Часть 3: Восхождение , Стойкость
Абсолютная власть , Иду на Вы! , Корона Ургаша , На задворках
Мир надо уничтожить... Чтобы создать свой...