Every time the decisions of the Arbitration Committee (AC) were criticized, someone from the AC would write that the AC doesn't get paid for this, people work on an enthusiastic basis, and sometimes the question would arise: what have you done for hip-hop in your time, and in general, first achieve something yourself.
Given the mechanism for electing the AC, when voting for new members is not held among players, but among the members of the AC, new members of the AC must first of all be loyal to the current members. Perhaps that's why Roger DAltavilla, who is new to the forum, was chosen for the AC last time, instead of Wicc, who allows himself to make critical statements. Accordingly, critics essentially have no opportunity to take action. In this regard, the first proposal is to change the mechanism for selecting the AC, making the voting universal, or, for example, with a requirement based on the length of registration/number of games played. Elections should not be held often, for example, once every two years – this seems like a sufficient time for officials to prove themselves.
Of the current members of the AC, I would vote for Pete, Dirty, and Mizrael. This, of course, is provided that the esteemed gentlemen are willing to continue doing this.
I would also like to see people who criticized the decisions of the AC in the AC.
In my opinion, the most revealing situation was the argument about the Rebellius-Kobra match. Rebellius's arguments were then more logical than the judges' decision, and Wicc also expressed himself very consistently. So, I nominate Rebellius and Wicc. //by the way, I still can't understand the hype around Rebe. I played offline with him last year and didn't have any problems. And Peterius has already written an election program for him in the neighboring thread// I will also nominate myself – it's not just about criticizing, I can also get things done.
If we talk about the parameter "willing to entrust the review of your matches and trust in making decisions," then there are not so many such people on the forum, I won't list them yet, I will vote if someone from them gets on the ballot.
As always, a thoughtful post from Sanin, unlike the clowns who rushed in: KobRa_RR, Dagr, R@sIM, Dark.
Dirty_Player raised a serious issue, and you are pushing the topic into a flame war.
