Mafia: general discussions.

for the second case, there is an alternative: when a role with 80% protection, some mega-cool maniac, suddenly sees his red nickname in the morning report...

Yeah. There's one such mega-cool guy, but he's not a maniac, but a defender, and not with 80%, but "only" with 75% right here:D. He either doesn't understand this, or he enjoys his death at the will of the coin in a 75 game.

Added 2 minutes ago

Percentages and randomness add more excitement to the game, which is needed in Mafia.

You can add a GM feature to your next game: "every turn, with a probability of X%, a random player and their entire team are instantly killed." This will definitely add a lot of excitement, without which Mafia is not Mafia:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:.