Mafia: general discussions.

That's why they should be given a medium-strength role in some situations.

I would appreciate it if you could explain how these "25-50%" of this "medium-strength role" are better than a one-time, ordinary defense.

No one has any complaints about random redirection.

I do have complaints about it. I would never use this ability if I received a role with it, except in special cases like 89 Mafia on the last turn. But even then, the city didn't get anything out of it; it would have been better to redirect to the chosen target, but as a one-time ability. By the way, this was the only time when randomness played in my favor.

I calculated the role of a maniac with five invulnerable players.

There haven't been any roles like that yet; don't talk nonsense.

CHANCE FAITH HOPE

In short, I understand... Those who enjoy games with all sorts of lotteries and other games of chance like randomness; those who prefer to think and plan do not. That's all.