Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

He decided on his own

He drew his own conclusion

He drew his own conclusion based on his own conclusion

And presented it on behalf of the group

And for this

I didn't draw a conclusion; I hoped to get answers to these questions, addressed to you personally. "Don't make assumptions for me" (c)

Added 13 minutes later

What made you think that the replay was scheduled because of a fairly won game?

I already wrote about why I thought so.
And since you ignored the main point of my message again, I will repeat:
1) Did Redwait violate the rules of fair play?
2) According to which rule was the replay scheduled?