Skip to content

Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

User Avatar
#1056
Auto-translated
Dirty_Player
Timur, I think you don't understand the difference between a bug and an abuse/exploit.
Kostya, yes, I don't understand many things, that might be the case too, but in this situation, I don't understand the decision of the Arbitration Committee (AK), taking into account (although I swore not to repeat myself, but still, maybe someone will see it and answer at least one of the points):
a) Nitro and Redwhite knew about the Admiral's Hat. They were on equal footing! I'm most interested in whether the AK took this into account? And why are those who support the AK's decision to replay the game or even award Red a loss ignoring it?
b) There have already been precedents for this abuse, and they have been discussed on the forum. The AK doesn't live in the wilderness, and I think they saw the topic, if not all members of the AK, then at least most of them.
c) I don't know about you, but I personally haven't noticed any masochistic tendencies or a tendency to self-flagellation in Nitro.
He himself, weighing all the pros and cons, wrote that he recognizes the defeat. And I suspect it wasn't easy for him to do, after all, it wasn't a fun game, but a game for a place in a serious tournament group, and the AK kindly brought the replay on a silver platter. It is up to the participant of this game to judge the fairness/unfairness of the AK's decision, and he has made his choice.

Although, who am I kidding, it's much easier to give your assessment of another person, based on nothing, in order to strengthen your position as a knight :).

I've said it a hundred times, I haven't written or said anywhere, and I'm not going to express my personal opinion regarding the moral side of this act. It has nothing to do with the matter.

And in general, I'm amazed at how a conversation smoothly flows from one topic to another. I wouldn't be surprised if the discussion continues and, in a couple of pages, you move on to politics.
241-568-808