Mafia 93. In the Name of the Moon! ☾

It's unlikely that inactivity is the reason.

That's why something doesn't make sense. It's unlikely that an unlimited guard and healer would refuse to use Night Defense on the first night. And it turns out that if Yashura was protected, then no one was healed, and vice versa. And the excuse for the absence of Night Defense from Aino Minako (did I spell the name correctly?) as not wanting to waste protection on the first night doesn't sound very good.