I don't know... Even though I'm a newbie, I think creating such a thread could spark a serious conflict, leading to unspoken and hidden resentment because your name wasn't on the list... And generally, it could ruin the relationship between forum members.
But there will definitely be at least a small positive effect.
P.S. The main thing is that they don't ask to create an IronAxe-style ranking table later, like "50 top respected forum members";)