Mafia 90. The Tale of Oldforest.

Can someone tell me why use those poor profiles, which are quite sparse for everyone, and in half of the Heroes of Might and Magic games, when it's easier to create hints based on quests?
For example, musical instruments: a list is created, players choose any available instrument from the list, and a hint is generated specifically for that instrument (there’s plenty of facts and information about them in wikis and not only there – take the magic violin as an example).
But even just using the wiki, you can encrypt a lot of things.
Otherwise, anything could be used: actors, directors, generals, tarot decks, countries... basically anything that has information available.