Mafia 90. The Tale of Oldforest.

And by the way, I suggested killing the Warlock with the Priest, not just leaving him.

And a sane Priest wouldn't do that. Everyone seems to have forgotten about the Fire Elemental's special ability...

Added 1 minute ago

Would you, being a civilian, attack another civilian so aggressively?

Well, in principle, yes. If I mistakenly think he's a Mafia member.