Skip to content
#1271
Auto-translated
The game between Yegor Korobeynikov and Dark30 from some round of OFB-8, with a decision made based on the save file.








Why was it acceptable in this game to make a decision after the time limit expired, especially at such an early stage of the game (turn 131)?
Why wasn't a decision made based on the save file in my game after a much later turn (217) had passed?
Or is that what it's called now?
Pit for LM
We try to run FB Tournaments in a varied way, without using standard schemes...
This cannot affect judging! This cannot involve changing the rules after the tournament has ended. The tournament is over when all results have been approved.
Variability in judging schemes is nothing more than subjectivism. How can we then talk about an objective decision if
Pit for LM
The decision regarding this game was made collectively: ... taking into account the participants' positions in the tournament (both were contenders and the result was important for both)...
All participants in the tournament are equal, and the approach to evaluating game positions should be the same and impartial, regardless of their status - whether it's a friendly game or a tournament game, etc. If you swap these games from different rounds, the result should be the same, but Cobra would have nothing to cling to then; he would need some help. Thus, the AC itself admitted that it makes decisions based on the circumstances (the players' interests), which is strictly prohibited, rather than on the evaluation of the game result. Therefore, all further arguments will be meaningless against the authoritarianism of certain categories.
P.S. The authorship of the crazy idea of transferring a conditional result from one game in a tournament to another tournament (how absurd does that sound) belongs to a dirty player (as he himself admits).
P.P.S. Cobra was offered the option of playing a new FB game before all this happened, but he bravely refused, suggesting three games, and immediately admitting that it was a joke.
Don't change the rules after the tournament has ended; 7 participants had already been clearly determined, but someone is constantly haunted by a weak Buchholz score.
Attachments 4
4 files attached • Total size: 50.5 KB
Summer 2013


Statistics

Welcome our newest member: Фёдор Фёдорович