OFB-8

Global

Games

Olden Era

Heroes VII

Heroes VI

Heroes V

Heroes IV

Heroes III

Might&Magic

Heroes II

Heroes I

King's Bounty

H and M&M

Others

Community

Tavern

Town Hall

Roha's tours

Mode

No background Wide layout

Language

Content

Interface

Posts, wiki & tournaments are authored in English & Russian. Site labels translate to your interface choice.

rebellious

Registered: 11/23/2007

Posts: 1,257

#1227 9/6/2014 6:27 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Roger DAltavilla

In the HellLighT vs. bubuch match, the save files were examined by players because they believed there was a violation of the red rush rule. After reviewing the situation, it turned out that the rule was not violated. However, since the save files were examined, a replay was impossible.
When evaluating the save, all judges declared a draw.

Players did not have the right to examine the save files in a disputed situation; they should have appealed to the judges, right? And since both violated the rules, shouldn't both be disqualified, resulting in a score of zero for both, or a replay? Instead, those who violated the rules are being rewarded. It seems that the results of the games were being tied to the tournament situation rather than the actual situation on the map.

Summer 2013