Auto-translated
The logic is interesting, and there's something to it, but here's one point:
- what should happen to a person who honestly won against someone who withdrew from a tournament? Someone who spent their time and energy (and often, it's not some clueless newbie who would lose anyway, but someone like Yuri and others. Let's say you beat Yuri somehow, and then he withdraws, and your legitimate point should turn into zero? If I were offered that, I would be extremely happy.
10 characters.