Based on the opponent's report, it seems he initially took 112, and then, after the rematch, he took another 111. It seems correct, considering their rematches.
P.S. If, for example, you can't reach the opponent's troops with 116, but you can capture a lumber mill, is that considered a match? There are no armies there, but it still belongs to the opponent.
A match is considered a direct contact between players, i.e., any battle between them (a battle between any heroes, a battle with the garrison of an enemy castle or mine).
Also, capturing an empty castle or an unguarded mine is not a match.
If you visit a friend, the door is open, but he's not home – no match occurred.